The Yellow Wallpaper vs. Bluebeard

The Yellow Wallpaper vs. Bluebeard

!.?. !? Stella ENG 4U1 Monday, September 16, 2013 The Prescription to Insanity vs. Interest Saves the Cat Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper” was published in 1899. This story was based upon her own personal experience with severe depression which she underwent a series of unusual treatment for. “The Yellow Wallpaper” is a story about a lady who suffers and has been detected by her partner with “temporary nervous depression” (Gilman, 1).

The story of “Bluebeard” written by Charles Perrault is one of the timeless fairy tales that children are told by their moms and dads, however the part about the murder of his spouses is removed and replaced with something better for kids. “Bluebeard” is a story about a wealthy man, a wonderful key and his other half who unwillingly consents to marry him even though he has a blue beard that made him “frightfully unsightly” (Perrault,1).

In my opinion, these two stories have absolutely nothing in common expect the fact that although they both have the exact same extraordinary symbols like colors, rooms, home, crucial and siblings, these symbols indicate and represent different things in the stories. The ‘yellow wallpaper’ in this story symbolizes sickness and an ill mindset. It is driven by the storyteller’s sense that the wallpaper is a passage she need to interpret and it also signifies that it is something that affects her straight. The wallpaper develops its meaning throughout the story. At first it appears simply undesirable: it is ripped, stained, and an “unclean yellow” (Gilman, 2).

The worst part is the probably shapeless pattern, which mesmerizes the narrator as she attempts to find out how it is organized. After looking at the paper for hours, she sees an unusual sub-pattern behind the main pattern “like a lady stooping down and creeping about behind that pattern” (Gilman, 5) noticeable only in particular light. The female represents a desperate female, constantly crawling and stooping, trying to find an escape from behind the primary pattern which has pertained to resemble the bars of a cage much like our narrator in your home.

In a typical sense, wallpaper is familial and modest, but Gilman skillfully uses this terrible, revolting paper as a symbol of the marital life that confines so many ladies. The ‘home’ itself represents a safe and secure location for someone and flexibility. Nevertheless, in this story it is not her own and she does not want to remain in it. The storyteller specifies that the house is “haunted” (Gilman, 1) which “there is something strange about it” (1 ). Although she acknowledges the appeal of the house and specifically what surrounds it” [T] he most lovely place! … think of English positions that you read about … (1 ), she constantly returns to her sensation that “there is something weird about your house”. Her sensation resembles a prophecy for the modification that takes place in her while she is at your house. In this technique, your house still is the shelter for her transformation. Your house does not take the shape of the standard symbol of security for the domestic activities of a female, but it permits and includes her improvement. The house also helps in her release, assisting her, her writing and her thoughts. These 2 actions establish because of the reality that she is kept in the house.

In Perrault’s “Bluebeard”, blue is an excellent sign because it is known as on of the coldest color. Although it is the inmost color, blue is the frailest color and rarely takes place in the natural world except as luminousness. It is considered clear, or severe, pure, and cold. Indifferent and unafraid, centered entirely upon itself, blue is not of this world: it stimulates the idea of eternity, calm, lofty, superhuman, inhuman even” (Chevalier 1982). Many of these symbolic qualities of blue relate well to Bluebeard who is cold with his fatal character.

His blue beard triggers individuals to fear him as an abnormal color for a beard or most things in the natural world. Another significant sign in this story is the ‘key’. The key in this tale has lots of symbolic meanings. First of all, a crucial represents power and/or wealth. They are used to lock away something precious. In folktales, a crucial symbolizes a secret yet to be solved “on the road to enlightenment and revelation” (Chevalier 1982). In this case, it represents a secret to the bride which should be fixed; Bluebeard offered his bride-to-be the key to give her admission and power in her new house.

This advantage comes with a warning for he forbids her entry into among the rooms revealing his absence of trust in her. Essentially, the key is a trap in this story because the use of the prohibited secret includes a death sentence however he did not tell her this– he just told her that she might expect his “simply anger and resentment” (Perrault, 2). Another point worth nothing is that, the better half will utilize the key to open the prohibited room and therefore she will be given a disclosure about the real nature of her husband.

All these signs are what made both stories satisfying to check out because they supplied insights into the lives of some individuals although Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper” was based on experience while Perrault’s “Bluebeard” was a folktale. The storyteller of “The Yellow Wallpaper” was biased because, in my opinion, of the truth that she wanted the readers to believe her a lot that she added a lot of her dissatisfaction in the room which led to some readers doubting her opinionated view.

In Perrault’s “Bluebeard”, though it was a folktale it had some aspects of pure humanity in it. Thus, both authors were successful in exposing some essential elements of human nature to us. Functions Cited Charlotte Perkins Gilman, The Yellow Wallpaper, released 1899 by Small & & Maynard, Boston, MA. Chevalier, Jean and Alain Gheerbrant. A Dictionary of Symbols, Second Edition. Equated by John Buchanan-Brown. New York: Penguin Books, 1982. Lang, Andrew. “Bluebeard. ” Heaven Fairy Book. University of Virginia Library’s Electronic Text Center, [1991]

You Might Also Like