“The Fall of the House of Usher” and “The Yellow Wallpaper”: A Comparison Introduction

Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper” has actually gotten large praise for its precise representation of madness and the signs attributed to psychological breakdowns (Shumaker 1985). While these signs might appear apparent from today’s mental viewpoint, Gilman was composing at the close of the 19th century when the discipline of psychology was still emerging out of a basic psychiatric approach to treating the mentally ill.

Though physicians have actually attempted to blog about the treatment of madness considering that ancient Greece, the history of insanity has usually been defined by a series of popular images, images that may have stunted the development of a medical design of mental illness: as a wild impracticality, a creative and corrupt gothic scary, a violent cruelty that needs to be confined in asylums, and last but not least as a simple nervous condition.

The critic Annette Kolodny recommends that modern readers of Gilman’s story probably discovered how to follow her imaginary representation of psychological breakdown by checking out the earlier stories of Edgar Allen Poe (Shumaker 1985), and indeed we can locate these strata of historic representations in both “The Yellow Wallpaper” and Poe’s “The Fall of your house of Usher.”

But where Poe’s depictions seem to verify unfavorable– and hence not therapeutically useful– stereotypes of insanity, Gilman tempers her representations through the emerging mental design, which permitted her to articulate a brand-new image preparing for the 20th century hope of treating psychological diseases through psychological expression. Background Gilman’s story portrays the psychological collapse of a late 19th century homemaker going through the Rest Cure, who grows increasingly consumed with a troubling wallpaper pattern.

It has actually been suggested that modern readers would have read the story as either a Poe-like study of madness, yet most modern critics focus on a feminist reading in which the wallpaper deliberately represents the “oppressive patriarchal social system” (Thrailkill 2002). Jane Thrailkill, in her essay about the mental ramifications of “The Yellow Wallpaper,” argues that this feminist reading may actually block the work done by the story to shift 19th century medical conventions surrounding mental disorder (Thrailkill 2002).

Gilman specified that whatever she wrote was for a purpose beyond simple literary home entertainment, which “The Yellow Wallpaper” was written in order to highlight the threats of specific medical practices, particularly to encourage Dam Mitchell to change the approach of his Rest Remedy for nervous ailments (which Gilman herself had actually unsuccessfully gone through) (Shumaker 1985, Thrailkill 2002).

In Gilman’s words, the story was, “… planned … to conserve individuals from going crazy, and it worked” (Thrailkill 2002). Like Gilman, Poe might also have suffered from mental disorder, however following the issues of his historical minute, Poe seems to have actually been more interested in the building of visual results rather of how those results might alter social and clinical point of views.

The only reference of a remedy in Poe’s tale is the “vague hope” that reading a book will relieve excitement (Poe 2003). However, Gilman’s techniques of representing madness plainly derive from Poe; they both utilize an “inspired manic voice,” unnamed storytellers, anxious characters with no diagnosable disease, a defiant foregrounding of the imagination, and a haunting state of mind with logical design that has actually been thought about Poe’s signature style (Davison 2004).

Published sixty years previously, Poe’s “The Fall of your home of Usher” in specific seems to prepare for “The Yellow Wallpaper” in its manor setting and mad characterizations, and therefore can act as an opening point from which to trace the 19th century shifts in cultural and scientific representations of madness that culminate in Gilman’s tale. Analysis In “The Fall of your home of Usher,” an unnamed storyteller, visiting his old friend Roderick Usher, attempts to describe Roderick’s insanity through both external and internal indications of irrationality.

A lot of right away, Roderick’s hair is referred to as “wild” and of “Arabesque expression,” which the narrator is not able to connect “with any basic idea of humanity” (Poe 2003). Similarly, Roderick’s way strikes the storyteller with “an incoherence– a disparity,” and his voice is compared to that of “the lost drunkard, or the irreclaimable eater of opium” (Poe 2003), all of which mark his social difference as not easy to understand.

After the entombment of his sister, Roderick’s external madness heightens: he wanders with “unequal, and objectless action,” has a “more dreadful hue” of face, a “species of mad hilarity in his eyes,” a “restrained hysteria in his entire attitude,” and speaks in a “gibbering whispering” (Poe 2003). But all of these are, as the storyteller puts it, “the mere mysterious vagaries of madness” (Poe 2003). When it pertains to representing the internal procedure of mental breakdown, Poe (at least in this story) still only describes Roderick’s irrationality from an external and stereotypical position.

Roderick describes his condition as a “awful recklessness” that will force him to “abandon life and reason,” he is “enchained by certain superstitious impressions,” and experiences “melancholy” and “hypochondria” (2 terms connected with earlier misconceptions of madness) (Poe 2003). The only time we see the unreasonable idea process represented remains in Roderick’s monologue about entombing his sis alive, which utilizes dashes, italics, and capitalization to suggest an anxious desperation, as in Poe’s “The Tell-Tale Heart”.

On the other hand, Gilman drops almost all of these external and stereotyped descriptions of insanity in her story, focusing instead on a devoted performance of unreasonable thought procedures, in specific the narrator’s growing fixation with the yellow wallpaper. Early in the story, the storyteller states that she loves her room, “all but that horrid wallpaper,” however within a couple of pages this declaration is reversed; the storyteller becomes fond of the space “perhaps due to the fact that of the wallpaper.

It stays in my mind so” (236 ). The wallpaper gradually takes control of the storyteller’s thought process, breaking into other observations without transition, as when the narrator looks out her window and sees “a charming nation, filled with great elms and velvet meadows. This wallpaper has a kind of sub-pattern …” (235 ). Ultimately she “follows that pattern about by the hour” until there are couple of passages in the text that are not about the wallpaper (238 ).

As her obsession grows, the narrator ends up being paranoid that her husband and stepsister are “covertly effected by it,” and she’s hence “identified that no one will find [the pattern] out however myself” (239 ). Regardless of her initial loathing of the wallpaper pattern, by the end of the story the storyteller’s obsession is so consuming that she claims, “I don’t want to leave until I have found it out” (240 ). Instead of being straight told that the storyteller is enchained by her impressions like Roderick Usher, we are more realistically revealed those irrational impressions at work in the mind.

Another method for representing impracticality is to cast it versus a more logical point of view, which both these stories do. Poe’s storyteller, for instance, declares to logically explain away the otherwise inexplicable occasions of “The Fall of your house of Usher” while recording Roderick’s breakdown (Gruesser 2004). The house’s strange atmosphere “should have been a dream;” his uneasiness is “due to the bewildering influence of the gloomy furniture;” the storm is “simply an electrical phenomena” (Poe 2003).

And yet the uncertainty of events displayed in this narrative unreliability suggests that the storyteller may himself be going mad. After describing Roderick’s wild appearance, the narrator says, “it was no wonder that his condition horrified– that it effected me,” and begins to feel “the wild impacts of [Roderick’s] own great yet remarkable superstitions” (Poe 2003). This failure to rely on his own understandings triggers the storyteller to run away aghast when your house collapses, where a more rational or untouched individual might first summon the servants or police (Gruesser 2004).

According to John Gruesser, the challenge in Poe’s usage of unreliability is that he sets reason in opposition to the supernatural, straddling the Gothic/Fantastic genre where supernatural occasions are more likely than their reasonable descriptions. This supernatural possibility appears to reduce the question of whether madmen are constantly delusional or can speak the reality, which becomes central for Gilman’s story. “The Yellow Wallpaper” likewise uses a logical perspective in the character of her partner and doctor John, who is “useful in the extreme.

He has no patience with faith, an extreme scary of superstitious notion” (235 ). Not only does John rationalize the upsetting nature of your house as a draught, but he also tries to rationalize the storyteller’s mental disorder, calling it “a short-term anxious anxiety– a slight hysterical tendency” (234 ). As we will see, this description of insanity as simply nerves will end up being a big issue for 19th century conversations on mental disorder, and as such comes off as much more scientifically realistic than explaining madness through the supernatural.

Gilman also has her narrator effort to justify her own insanity, beginning the story with her claim of being “ordinary people,” and continuing this attempt to rationalize even through her psychological degeneration: “it is getting to be an excellent effort for me to think straight. Just this nervous weakness I suppose” (238 ). While this use of undependable explanations resembles Poe’s, it reads as more reasonable due to the fact that Gilman frames her story in such a way that rejects the Gothic discourse of supernatural explanations.

Despite its ultimate medical ineffectuality, the label of “nerves” is among the clearest literary representations of madness attempting to describe or deny its psychological character. “Real!– worried– very, extremely terribly anxious I had been and am;” claims the storyteller of Poe’s “The Telltale Heart,” “but why will you state that I seethe?” (Poe 2003). The Usher family insanity in “The Fall of the House of Usher” is also coded; Roderick attempts to pass off their “constitutional and … household evil” as a “simple worried affection” (Poe 2003).

He has an extreme “worried agitation … and intense physical disease,” and “a morbid acuteness of the senses” that makes most food, garments, smells, light, and sounds unbearable (Poe 2003). Madeline is diagnosed with a “settled lethargy, a progressive running out,” due to the fact that whatever is really wrong with her “long baffled the skill of her doctors” (Poe 2003). Whether these characters are really mad, one gets the sensation that the word “nerves” is utilized by Poe to describe or make clear the Usher household condition for the mid-19th century reader, indicating that it may be a biological instead of ethical or supernatural disorder.

The narrator in “The Yellow Wallpaper” also articulates her condition as anxiousness, however within the late-19th century occlusion of madness as simply nerves, this term seems to indicate less an explanation as much as an excuse or rejection of any deeper mental issue. As the storyteller states in what is quickly checked out as a flippant tone, “I never utilized to be so sensitive, I believe it is due to this nervous condition,” and “obviously it is just anxiety” that causes her actions to require a greater effort (235 ).

Though her partner has informed the narrator that her nervous case is not major, she reveals a brand-new discontentment with this medical diagnoses; “these anxious difficulties are dreadfully dismal” (236 ). This almost paradoxical however clearly important representation of worried conditions marks a break from Poe’s story, however a lot more significantly shows the battle Gilman went through in her own life versus the American medical market’s changing view of mental disorders.

Though “The Yellow Wallpaper” was composed to specifically resolve the Rest Remedy, as Thrailkill recommends, the story assisted shift the medical paradigm from looking at the client’s body to listening to their words (Thrailkill 2003). The story is penetrated with this desire to talk beyond the traditional psychiatric design: not only is the storyteller forbidden to compose, but her doctor spouse just sees her physical improvements of “flesh and color,” paternally dismissing any of her objections (240 ).

To compose, however, is the one thing the storyteller regularly feels would make her well; it is a relief to “say what I feel and think”. Thrailkill uses a reading that Gilman’s narrator in the beginning imitates Mitchell’s physiological technique in taking a look at the wallpaper, which then shifts to the articulation of a story surrounding the female in the paper, essentially equating the narrator to a medical text (Thrailkill 2003).

We do not require to stretch so far nevertheless, as the story is currently framed as a diary or journal, that is, it claims to be the expression of an individual’s real experience. Though the storyteller has trouble writing, she continues to compose, honestly detailing the thoughts, sensations, and visions attending her mental breakdown in a way that expects the 20th century mental recognition that insanity consists of a genuine lucidity (Davison 2004).

A psychologically unstable individual’s journal thus represents precisely the sort of “irrelevant story” that can treat, and which any sympathetic reader can comprehend as a legitimate mental experience of somebody who is no longer viewed as socially other or “mad, bad, and hazardous.” Subsequently, while Poe’s “The Fall of the House of Usher” comes off as simply an entertaining story about some stereotypical madmen, Gilman’s “The Yellow Wallpaper” is eventually an emotionally real portrayal of the subjective experience of somebody going mad.

You Might Also Like