Romeo and Juliet– to Pardon or Not to Pardon
To pardon or not to pardon an essay Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare is a disaster about 2 young enthusiasts, whose enthusiastic love is ended by the fated death of both celebrations. The sad conclusion of their young love is likewise triggered by many others besides the lead characters Romeo and Juliet; some shall be pardoned; while some shall be penalized. Juliet’s cherished mother-figure- the Nurse, does not deserve the audience’s reject. Friar John, the Franciscan monk who plays a part in the death of Romeo, must likewise, be forgiven.
Friar Laurence and Capulet, on the other hand, have lots of faults that contribute to the end results, of which I will talk about further. From the extremely starting in Act 1 scene 3, the Nurse of Juliet Capulet is introduced to us. Woman Capulet is asking to see her daughter. Rather of searching for Juliet herself, she goes to the Nurse for her whereabouts. “Woman Capulet: Nurse, where’s my daughter? Call her forth to me.” (1. 3. 1) From this first look we can boldly assume that maturing in a grand household like the Capulets, Juliet is more familiarized with her Nurse instead of her mother.
Another example is when the Nurse recalls Juliet’s childhood and how she breastfed her. It was very unusual throughout the Elizabethan time for another person to breastfeed one’s daughter instead of the biological mother. This is also part of the reason that there is such a gap in between the older generation– Girl Capulet, and the more youthful generation- Juliet in the future in the play. ‘T is considering that the earthquake now eleven years; and she was wean ‘d-I shall never forget it- of all the days of the year, upon that day. For I had actually then laid wormwood to my dug, Being in the sun under the dove-house wall. (1. 3. 4-28) Juliet describes her mom as “Madam” rather of “mother” or “mum” is another indication of their strangeness. However, the Nurse is very dear to Juliet; from later scenes we will discover more about the relationship in between mistress and servant. In Act 2 scene 4, the Nurse satisfies Romeo personally for the very first time. Mercutio and Benvolio jest and make fun of her. Romeo then explains that his friends are people who delight in taunts and laughter, so the Nurse should forgive them for their insults. The Nurse is relieved that Romeo is a gentleman; Juliet’s taste for men is not too obscene certainly.
She likes Romeo and appreciates her girlfriend’ choice. “Nurse: I will inform her, sir, that you do demonstration; which, as I take it, is a gentlemanlike offer.” (2. 4. 170) We now know that the Nurse’s taste for Romeo is genuine. She is the only other adult who understands about Romeo and Juliet’s secret affair besides Friar Laurence. As a great keeper of secrets, she passed on the message of their wedding event time to Juliet without rousing anyone else. In Act 3 scene 2, when Juliet discovers of Romeo’s slaying of Tybalt and his banishment, she gets into tears and would not be comforted.
The thoughtful and caring Nurse used herself as much as handle the hazardous course of obtaining the banished Romeo from Friar Laurence’s cell. Hie to your chamber. I’ll discover Romeo To comfort you; I wot well where he is. Hark ye, your Romeo will be here at night. I’ll to him; he is concealed at Laurence’ cell. (3. 2. 138-41) When the Nurse gets to the Friar’s cell, Romeo is lying on the floor snuggled like a coward; he is regreting over his banishment. The Friar scolds him with a speech about womanish worries and misbehaviour.
Upon hearing Romeo’s godfather’s harsh words, the Nurse exclaims her appreciation for an educated male: “O Lord, I could have remain ‘d here all the night to hear great counsel. O, what knowing is!” (3. 3. 159) This reveals a want of education and wit in the Nurse, who is of a low birth. This will connect to her biased judgement and reasonable views of life. The next scene when the Nurse appears again, dramatic climax occurs. Lord Capulet is storming with rage at Juliet’s disobedience; children were objects had by their fathers back in the Elizabethan time; Juliet is a very uncommon case.
When the Lord threatens to disown his child and calls her repulsive names, Juliet kneels down and asks for forgiveness. The Nurse, who is watching the whole family drama, might not take it any longer. She stands up to speak boldly versus her employer. As a servant, that is an extremely dangerous and unusual thing to do. Her love for Juliet greatly exceeds the concerns for her own security and the dangers of losing her task. “Nurse: God in paradise bless her! You are to blame, my lord, to rate her so. “(3. 5. 169) Lord Capulet dismisses the Nurse as a prattler, and that she should hold her tongue from gossiping and mumbling.
When the upset moms and dads lastly leave Juliet’s chamber, the Nurse sits down to recommend Juliet that marrying Paris is the best thing to do in her situation, for Romeo attempts not come back to visit her. Her comparison of Romeo with Paris is offensive to Juliet, and her sudden modification of assistance disgusts Juliet. Romeo is get rid of ‘d; and all the world to nothing, That he dares ne’er come back to challenge you; Or, if he do, it requires must be by stealth. Then, considering that the case so stands as now it doth, I believe it best you wed with the County.
O, he’s a lovely gentleman! Romeo’s a dishclout to him. An eagle, madam, Hath not so green, so fast, so fair an eye As Paris hath. Beshrew my very heart, I think you enjoy in this second match, For it excels your first; or if did not, Your first is dead; or ’twere as excellent he were, As living here and you no usage of him. (3. 5. 215-27) This tip is well-meant; the Nurse just desires Juliet to be happy, and to her realistic consider as a servant, it implies quiting a chaotic and mismanaged marriage with Romeo and exchange for a stable and efficient one.
From Juliet’s perspective, her relied on confidante, assistance, and help just dedicated a criminal activity of great betrayal, although we know that without her assistance or participation, Juliet could not have actually sustained a relationship with Romeo, and the young lovers might have perished previously due to their uncontrollable infatuation. The Nurse plays an important role in the play, and her faults from Juliet’s position need to not misguide the audience into blaming this poor servant who has one of the greatest hearts.
Another that must be pardoned is the minor character with the enormous role of a messenger. Friar John is responsible for the delivery of the news of Juliet’s fake death to Romeo; he is not able to finish his task due to the fact that of his quarantine. Suspecting that we both remained in a home Where the infectious pestilence did reign, Seal had actually up the doors, and would not let us forth; So that my speed to Mantua there was stay ‘d … I could not send it … nor get a messenger to bring it thee, So afraid were they of infection. (5. 2. 9-16)
Plague was a frightening thing back in the Elizabethan age; it was constantly looked after with great safety measure: isolation of the person and anybody else in contact with the pester. It was a severe and psychologically shocking experience. Friar John feared for his life when he was quarantined; it was not exclusively his fault that the letter might not be delivered. He tried but the quarantine prohibited him to have any interaction with the outside world. As much as it appears that Romeo’s death is brought on by Friar John the missed out on link, one can just blame fate.
There are the ones that ought to be pardoned, and there are the as soon as that must be penalized. Friar Laurence is such one. As Romeo’s godfather and Juliet’s last confidant, he is continuously abusing his power as a Franciscan monk. A holy person is anticipated to follow god’s assistance and laws, but Friar Laurence not just breaks the faith that he preaches, he likewise lies to others various times. He opposed Romeo’s abrupt change of love topics in the beginning, but he continues to overlook the guidelines of Verona; simply out of personal love for his god-son.
He achieved this by performing the wedding privately without any witnesses or contracts from either house. Come, come with me, and we will make Short-work; For, by your leave, you shall not stay alone Till Holy Church includes 2 in one. (2. 6. 34-37) Friar Laurence thinks that he is on an objective to reunite the families when so many others have attempted to do so without any obtain; they consist of Prince Escalus. From this we can presume that the Friar has plenty of himself and over-confidant. He believes that with his power and Romeo and Juliet’s marriage, he could achieve the impossible.
He egged the young couple on by formulating plans and arranging conferences for them; if only he had declined to be participated in the teenagers’ infatuation in Act 2 scene 3, Romeo and Juliet’s love might have broken down with the passing of time and commitment-less affection. Friar Laurence is likewise a hypocrite who provides guidance however does not follow them himself. Prior to weding Romeo and Juliet he said: “Carefully and slow; they stumble that run quickly. “(2. 3. 94) and “Love reasonably; long love doth so; too speedy arrives as tardy as too slow. “(2. 6. 4) Friar Laurence never obeyed his own preaching for he wed Romeo and Juliet quickly. Regardless of the excellent counsel, he contradicts with himself; Friar Laurence is a charlatan indeed. The next scene of severe and bad choices takes place when Juliet is confronted with the dilemma of double marital relationship or being disowned by her family. Her last resort is Friar Laurence, who appears to be on Romeo and Juliet’s side throughout the whole play; though we as the audience know that his judgements were not the best so far. Seeing the desperate Juliet, Friar Laurence offers her with the potion plan of which he thought would be fail evidence.
Providing a death potion to a thirteen year old is not the best thing he has ever done. Take thou this vial, being then in bed, And this distilled alcohol drink thou off; When presently through all thy veins shall run A cold and drowsy humour; for no pulse Shall keep his native development, however surcease … (4. 1. 95-97) The Friar has actually not taken step to guarantee that the plan is created well enough; he did not picture the possibilities of Romeo not getting the message. He needs to have offered the letter to more than a single person in case it encounters any difficulty or gets lost.
This error expense Romeo and Juliet’s lives. The next fatal error he makes is when he stresses and deserts the ravaged and scared Juliet in the Capulet’s burial place. As an adult and the accountable individual of the whole state of affairs, he should have made certain that the over psychological Juliet is with him so that she does not do anything silly. Friar Laurence is currently very familiarized with the young couple’s spontaneous actions; he ought to have forecasted Juliet’s suicide. Friar Laurence: Come, go, excellent Juliet, I dare no longer stay. Juliet: Go, get thee for this reason, for I will not away. Exit Friar Laurence] (5. 3. 159-160) In the last scene, Friar Laurence lastly has the heart to admit all his sins to the citizens. It is an ironic scene, for instead of being admitted to, the Friar is confessing his own sins to others. He is the character with the most control of the story; had he not gone with his own suggestions that weding Romeo and Juliet would be too rash, Romeo and Juliet would not have ended up dead. Lastly, Lord Capulet is an antagonist who also prevents Romeo and Juliet from maintaining their love.
He too should have followed his own suggestions about his daughter being too young to wed. In Act 3 scene 5, Capulet chooses that Juliet ought to wed Paris since he wishes it so. He believes in the Elizabethan custom of weding children away like ownerships. An you be mine, I’ll offer you to my friend; An you be not, hang, plead, starve, die in the streets, For, by my soul, I’ll ne’er acknowledge thee, Nor what is mine will never do thee great … (3. 5. 193-197) It is his continuous pressure for Juliet to marry and threats to renounce her name that forces Juliet onto her death bed.
Capulet’s speech in this scene is really harsh and cold-hearted. Telling a child that he wants that she had actually never been born is ruthless and significantly repulses the readers. If just he had respected his child’s wishes and delayed the wedding event up until Juliet is prepared, the young couple might have discovered a method to appeal to their particular households about their love and marital relationship; a way that the feud might potentially have actually ended instead of a disaster. Juliet’s relationship with her dad is really strained and Lord Capulet is shown as an unfavorable and disliked character to the audience.
The play in many elements might have ended happily if Romeo and Juliet were not so lustful and reckless. Killing Tybalt, drinking toxin, and stabbing oneself with a dagger are examples of Romeo and Juliet’s self-inflicted deaths. Those others such as Friar Laurence and Capulet are likewise to blame. Characters figure out destiny not possibility; the plot of this play is directed by over-nosey and commanding grownups; along with thoughtless and careless teens. Every citizen influences the awful story. To pardon or not to pardon, that is the question.