StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why does Galen Strawson think free will is impossible Do you agree Why or why not - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
According to Strawson, there is a fundamental sense of the phrase free, yet there are several extents to which the word is false or construed falsely. Strawson is…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.1% of users find it useful
Why does Galen Strawson think free will is impossible Do you agree Why or why not
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why does Galen Strawson think free will is impossible Do you agree Why or why not"

Insert Introduction A British philosopher and literary critic, Galen John Strawson (b. 1952) has contributed prolifically to metaphysics and the study of mind. Strawson believes that free will is not possible. Thesis statement Galen Strawson held that whether determinism is true or otherwise, moral responsibility is provably impossible. Strawson’s argument against free will begins with the discussions on the concept of free will and its meaning. According to Strawson, there is a fundamental sense of the phrase free, yet there are several extents to which the word is false or construed falsely.

Strawson is categorical that understanding the word free is important since from it ensue concepts such as free agents and accountability. Strawson argues that the word free is elusive and nearly inapplicable since feelings, beliefs, practices and attitudes that color the manner in which the world is conceived and interacted with and therefore extensively affect the way people as free agents conduct themselves. Strawson defines freedom in terms of moral responsibility as the capability of being truly responsible for personal actions (Strawson, 16).

Again, Strawson is of the persuasion that since feelings, beliefs, practices and attitudes affect man’s choices and actions, they inform the experience people have and being responsible. This affects the manner in which people make choices in light of rewards and punishment since rewards and punishment are forces and tokens of socialization and acculturization. In other words, rewards and punishment are ways by which a society expresses approval or disapproval on an act or a choice, or the consequences of the same.

Counter-objections to Strawson’s Arguments There are philosophers who have counter-argued Strawson’s standpoint on the dismissal and definition of freedom. These philosophers are categorical that Strawson fails to define the freedom that is in question and that Strawson fails to state whether the freedom is real, imagined or a property that almost all adult human persons [at least in the West] believe to possess. The crux of the matter herein is that to say that one does not understand what freedom really is, is to be bereft of the most basic understanding of the society that one belongs to and this claim is therefore untenable.

Simply put, the charge is that freedom is something whose comprehension is easily grasped and that Strawson is therefore engaging in semantics. Response to objections to Strawson’s argumentsWorks Cited Strawson, Galen. Freedom and Resentment and other Essays. London: OUP, 1974. Print

Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why does Galen Strawson think free will is impossible Do you agree Why Essay”, n.d.)
Why does Galen Strawson think free will is impossible Do you agree Why Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1641693-why-does-galen-strawson-think-free-will-is-impossible-do-you-agree-why-or-why-not
(Why Does Galen Strawson Think Free Will Is Impossible Do You Agree Why Essay)
Why Does Galen Strawson Think Free Will Is Impossible Do You Agree Why Essay. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1641693-why-does-galen-strawson-think-free-will-is-impossible-do-you-agree-why-or-why-not.
“Why Does Galen Strawson Think Free Will Is Impossible Do You Agree Why Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/philosophy/1641693-why-does-galen-strawson-think-free-will-is-impossible-do-you-agree-why-or-why-not.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why does Galen Strawson think free will is impossible Do you agree Why or why not

The Problem of Induction by David Hume

Furthermore, Hume offers a solution to theoretical skepticism by distinguishing between the type of skepticism inquired about by philosophers, and the skepticism you should engage in everyday life.... eter strawson seems to offer a solution to the problem of induction, by pointing out that Hume applies rules of deductive reasoning to inductive reasoning, to make it seem they are not rational.... nbsp;However Hume does not wish to level all knowledge and inquiry....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Leading theories of free will

Hard determinism, as described earlier, claims that free will is inexistence.... In the research paper “Leading theories of free will” the author contracts and compares three leading theories of free will: Libertarianism, Hard determinism, Compatabilism.... free will has been described as; having the ability to make decisions or choices, devoid any kind of limitations.... As such, anybody who desires to make a decision out of free will, should not be influenced by any external forces or interferences whilst making such a decision (Kim et al, 2009)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Universal and Free Healthcare in the United States

hellip; However, I am not sure, as to how many of you agree with the premise that a natural extension of this social ideal makes free healthcare mandatory Hence, I would like to establish that free healthcare is not only a human necessity, but also a realizable possibility. (explanation) 2.... Motivation: I am assuming that none of you disagrees with the fact that every ailing fellow human being should have access to some mode of treatment and recovery and taking care of the sick and the suffering is the essential duty of every progressive society....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Effects Of Political Correctness

But why use an offensive word when a non-offensive one works just as nicely?... However, when you use the term, you are making at two assumptions: 1) that the person is an American, and 2) that the person is African.... If one chooses to do something that dos more harm than good, it is considered unreasonable or unintelligent.... Politically correct language promotes the “I have a right to be not offended” mindset, which is in direct contradiction to the idea of free speech....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Effects Of The Society In The Black Community

Looking through the lens of galen strawson's “Hard Determinism” the movie seems to prove the philosophy that no individual is truly responsible since it requires the ideal determination of the self.... Boyz N Hood is a renowned film directed by John Singleton and released in 1991....
5 Pages (1250 words) Case Study

Poverty and Wealth

Suppose you tend to cry when you are hurt, does it mean do you always cry when you are hurt? Socrates: Very well, then it is therefore the same with the soul.... It is therefore preposterous to think that he wanted to steal out of free will.... However, it was not purely free will on his part, because the fact that he has within him and working at the same time – the appetitive, spirited and rational desires – may have in fact deceived him....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Compatibilism View of Free Will

According to compatibilism, an action of the free will is an aspect of determinism (Salles 11).... Specifically, this theory hypothesizes that everything happening in the universe has a natural cause and purports the existence of free will.... Consequently, compatibilism defines free will as the acts that are… Fundamentally, free will depends on its use in the conventional society (Salles 3).... In addition, the concept of compatibilism shows that people act according to or contrary to their free will (Salles 5)....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Do You Agree with Determinism or Compatibilism

This essay "do you agree with Determinism or Compatibilism" presents a philosophy that is called the soft version of determinism since it accepts that human actions are directed by some unseen force but at the same time it says that the human freewill also plays a major role.... Compatibilism associates free will to human actions whereas Determinism calls it an illusion.... ompatibilism denies the inevitable causation that every effect has some cause attached to it and that this cause and effect relationship is always so strong that humans cannot show interference and they don't possess any free will....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us