StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats - Article Example

Cite this document
Summary
From the paper "Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats" it is clear that this is an article that tries to cover too much ground in too short a space. A more thorough description of the small studies reported would have been much more useful empirical evidence…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats"

Article Summary: Comparing Achievement in Online and Face-to Face Formats. Schools Number and of Instructors Name Date of Submission (e.g., October 12, 2009) Article Summary: Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats. Introduction The article entitled “Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats (Dell, Low and Walker, 2010) is written by three senior educators in the field of education in the United States. It starts with the observation that online teaching and learning is growing in popularity in teacher education programs, and quotes statistics from other researchers to show that this trend is set to continue. The authors state that faculty members have mixed feelings about this, with some people showing enthusiasm for this new medium for teaching and learning, and others expressing concerns about possible problems in the quality of learning that students gain, and possible workload, administration and training pressures on faculty staff. The fundamental issue that the authors explore is whether learning online is better or worse for students than learning in a traditional face-to-face classroom situation. In order to find the answer to this question the authors devised a study in which student learning strategies and achievement in each of these two contexts are compared. The purpose of the article, then, is a straightforward comparison of online and face-to-face learning and it appears to prove that these two modes are equivalent in their outcomes. Analysis Before launching into their own fieldwork, the authors briefly summarize some of the large amount of literature that has been written on this field already. An important meta-analyisis by Bernard et al. (2004) is quoted, highlighting the fact that in some 200 studies on distance learning, which includes some online learning, the results were “mixed at best.” (Dell, Low and Wilker, 2010, p. 31) The authors note that Bernard’s review ends with a call for further research, and with a preliminary finding that variables like methodology and pedagogy are more important than media (i.e. combinations of online or standard teaching or books) in predicting achievement. The authors cite further studies which suggest online learning is no less effective and perhaps slightly more effective than traditional learning, but again with an emphasis on pedagogical variables such as 1) use of problem based learning strategies, 2) opportunity for mediated communication with the instructor, 3) course and content provided before class starting and 4) the use of video, and many more not mentioned fully. Course design, rather than delivery method, appears to be a critical factor in the literature, and it is suggested that, the design of some of the research done in this field leaves a lot to be desired. A key issue is the difficulty in collecting comparable data from two such different teaching and learning processes, since there is a tendency in the literature to describe the distance (or online) element in detail, but not to give as much information on the classroom instruction element. Having explained these methodological difficulties at length, the authors then introduce their own study, which turns out to be two separate studies, one of undergraduates studying educational psychology, and another of postgraduates studying human development and learning. Students in each group were randomly allocated to online or face-to-face teaching groups. Material was delivered in the same order, and in roughly equivalent time scales, to both sets of groups, and the authors mention, but do not much comment on, the role of “facilitators” in the online postgraduate group. The same instructor delivered both online and classroom versions of the programs. Following their own advice, the authors give an account of the delivery methods of both types of learning. The outline of how each group engaged with the material is rather sketchy, however, and it appears the authors are keen to highlight the overlap, and somewhat reluctant to go into detail about the differences which were bound to occur in the two types of learning group. A very thorough and blind grading system was described, in which the markers had no way of distinguishing which papers came from which group. In the undergraduate program no difference in the achievement levels of the online and classroom based groups was found, while in the graduate program, in two of the four assignments, the online learners achieved higher grades. The authors rightly advise caution because of low numbers involved, and other variables not being controlled. For some reason the authors return to a discussion of the secondary literature at the end of the article in their “conclusions” section, citing numerous studies that emphasize the role of the instructor, the fact that prior experience of online learner is not a predictor of success, the importance of higher level thinking skills, motivation factors, self- regulation etc. It is not clear what relevance these points have at this stage in the paper, and there is more than a suggestion that the lack of clear outcomes in the small studies described has prompted the authors to look elsewhere for something important to report. Despite the more positive results for online learning in the graduate group, the authors conclude that “Instructional platforms formats differ, but evidence strongly suggests that either type can be effectively designed and taught, leading to equally strong student learning outcomes.” This is a rather simplistic conclusion, which seems more than a little self-evident. Conclusion Overall this is a disappointing article which tries to cover too much ground in too short a space. A more thorough description of the small studies reported would have been much more useful empirical evidence. Alternatively, a thorough analysis of the secondary literature, which the authors launched into but did not finish, would have also made a valuable contribution to the field. As it is, however, the article reports its meager findings very briefly, and avoids the issue of how valid, or not, they might be. There is a hint that online learning might be better, but the authors dare not make an outright statement to this effect. This means that the article would not be particularly useful for use by other students, but it does point the reader to some further studies, notably Bernard et al. (2004) which look as if they might be more interesting. Works Cited Bernard, R. M., Abrami, P.C., Lou, Y. et al. (2004). How does distance education compare with classroom instruction? A meta-analysis of the empirical literature. Review of Educational Research 74 (3), 379-439. Dell, C.A., Low, C. and Wilker, J.F. (2010). Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats. MERLOT Journal of Online Learning and Teaching 6 (1), 30-42. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“EN102 Article 2 Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
EN102 Article 2 Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1579331-en102-article-2
(EN102 Article 2 Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
EN102 Article 2 Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1579331-en102-article-2.
“EN102 Article 2 Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1579331-en102-article-2.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats

Comparison and Contrast of Two Articles

Comparison and Contrast of Two Articles Your Name University Number and Name of Course Comparison and Contrast of Two Articles The article “Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats” by Dell, Low and Wilker (2010) explored which of the two learning mediums were most effective in teaching students.... In “Comparing Student Achievement in Online and Face-to-Face Class Formats,” Dell, Low and Wilker (2010) used the term online to refer to a form of teaching method that was used as a basis for comparison with the more traditional chalk and blackboard method of teaching, which has been practiced for years....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Impact of Family Issues: how does this Affect the Child's Academic Grades

They could also base their decision on how that student's teacher teaches his or her class.... When comparing the scores the main factor will be to look at their family structure to explain the change in academic achievement and its link with the changes in family structures.... 8 Whilst doing this research, if there is a tremendous difference in the academic achievement of the two groups, then the president of the church's youth committee will use the results of the study to create an after-school program to assist students in their school work and cope with the family changes in their home....
28 Pages (7000 words) Essay

Positive and Negative Impacts of ICT on Education

At the heart of current teaching and training efforts is the need for a blended learning model that brings together the synergy of online learning and face-to-face support strategies to help leverage knowledge assimilation and learning outcomes.... These can be a mix of various event-based activities such as face to face classrooms and online learning (Williams, 2002).... ICT can be used to selectively present case studies, tutorials, self-testing exercises, simulations or other online modules in place of lecture material....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Examination of the Effectiveness of Online Learning as Compared to Traditional Classroom Learning

The study will involve comparing student achievement levels using quantitative analysis of academic results and qualitative survey findings but the qualitative component will in addition seek to identify if there are any underlying differences in student interest and motivation.... One hundred participants will be drawn from the student population of Northcentral University School of Education with an equal number of students studying online and studying in classrooms....
21 Pages (5250 words) Research Proposal

A Collaborative Online Learning Design Based on Instructor and Learners Perspective

Online learning incorporates collaborative learning which is recognized as a great and worthwhile opportunity, not only in terms of allowing access for fellow students but also in giving them chances to work together so to make their learning take place online more effectively, as compared to the traditional face-to-face class (Tsai, 2011).... The paper "A Collaborative online Learning Design Based on Instructor and Learners' Perspective" states that individuals should have prior knowledge about the subject, and their level of knowledge and willingness to be in a group must be considered when creating a group....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Educational Settings in the Workplace

It is in the light of this that recruiters in such organizations must be conscious of the need for this diversity of skills and abilities and the most effective means of developing and utilizing them in the achievement of the aims and objectives of institutions such as the open and distance learning system (David)....
14 Pages (3500 words) Research Paper

Ability Groups: Do They Enhance or Hinder Children's Development and Attainment in Schools

Furthermore, these children did not seem to be experiencing problems socially or emotionally and were therefore not distracted in class.... Not only should the teacher consider academic skills based on standard assessment procedures, but also her observations of each student's personal characteristics, background.... The student's non-academic abilities, as specified by Gardner's Multiple Intelligences and the learning styles most preferable to the student must likewise be assessed I, for one, pondered on this, as some of my own students were unable to pass the learning outcomes in Mathematics even after several attempts....
32 Pages (8000 words) Essay

Twice Exceptionality on Gifted Student with Learning Disabilities

As this manual indicates, a reading disorder is noticed if a student's reading attainment, as determined by standardized assessments of reading comprehension or accuracy, is considerably below the acceptable levels and noticeably interferes with their educational achievement.... The author of the "Twice Exceptionality on Gifted student with Learning Disabilities" paper intends to explore gifted students with learning disabilities; identification, the impact of the twice-exceptionality; and the appropriate way of teaching them....
15 Pages (3750 words) Literature review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us