StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Good dictator, bad dictator article summary - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The purpose of this reaction paper is to summarize and make arguments in relation to the article “Good dictator, bad dictator: United Fruit Company and Economic Nationalism in Central America in the Twentieth Century” written by Marcelo Bucheli. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Good dictator, bad dictator article summary
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Good dictator, bad dictator article summary"

Reaction Paper THESIS MENT The purpose of this reaction paper is to summarize and make arguments in relation to the article “Good dictator, bad dictator: United Fruit Company and Economic Nationalism in Central America in the Twentieth Century” written by Marcelo Bucheli. SUMMARY Marcelo Bucheli in his article “Good dictator, bad dictator: United Fruit Company and Economic Nationalism in Central America in the Twentieth Century” addressed the pejorative term “Banana Republic”, which is often used to define small, retrograde, deprived, and unstable country with extensive corruption and a subservient association with the United States.

He further regarded United Fruit Company, the US multinational as a quintessential American colonialism in Central America. In this article, Bucheli argued that the strong affiliation of the company with the local dictators facilitated it to acquire considerable status in Latin America. He further illustrated the prevalence of three periods in Central American nationalism that impacted overall functioning of United Fruit. Accordingly, Bucheli related first period as an era of resistance in the context of labor movement, which witnessed by United Fruit relating to power and supportive nature of government.

Furthermore, he relates second period when United Fruit faced government opposition to its operations for the first time. The third period has been related with the target of seeking nationalism, wherein the company was forced to sale a few of its properties (Bucheli 1-42). Based on the above analysis, it can be summarized that alliances can survive as long as the multinationals facilitate the dictators to experience financial stability of the country. On the other hand, he argued that when the multinationals become powerless or their capabilities are reduced to provide adequate benefits to the dictators, they adopt rigid approaches to find out other alternative ways for gaining well-acknowledged reputation especially in Latin America (Bucheli 1-42).

RESPONSE AND ARGUMENTS I firmly agree with the response of the authors related with multinationals in the early part of 20th century. However, it would be not valid to support the same facts as stated by the author i.e. Bucheli in the current context of multinationals. I think that during the phase of 20th century, the governments of various nations were struggling with gaining power and were less focused upon developing financial conditions of their respective nations. However, it can be apparently observed that the present scenario is mostly concerned with economic development and welfare of the society rather than gaining power.

It can be affirmed that Bucheli is correct when he states that alliance between the multinationals and government last “as long as the multinational’s operations provide a constant flow of income and economic stability” (Bucheli 1-42). In my opinion, such action of the government can be firmly attributed with the ideology of “self-interested political attitude.” Moreover, it can be argued that United Fruit operated in the countries having unstable and poor economic background. It seems that because of such factor, the company established a broader dominance over these nations during the early period of its operations.

However, the gradual development and awareness amid the people of these countries in the later period may be the other major factor, which caused the decline of United Fruit. In conclusion, such instances as in the case of United Fruit are rarely visible as every country has incorporated broad policies and legislations to govern the activities of multinationals. Work Cited Marcelo Bucheli, “Good dictator, bad dictator: United Fruit Company and Economic Nationalism in Central America in the Twentieth Century.

” University of Illinois at Urbana (2006): 1-42. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Good dictator, bad dictator article summary Essay”, n.d.)
Good dictator, bad dictator article summary Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1626012-good-dictator-bad-dictator-article-summary
(Good Dictator, Bad Dictator Article Summary Essay)
Good Dictator, Bad Dictator Article Summary Essay. https://studentshare.org/history/1626012-good-dictator-bad-dictator-article-summary.
“Good Dictator, Bad Dictator Article Summary Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1626012-good-dictator-bad-dictator-article-summary.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Good dictator, bad dictator article summary

The Truth About Mass Shootings and Gun Controls

Name Tutor Course College Date The Truth about Mass Shootings and Gun Controls In the event of a national catastrophe, we are encapsulated with fear.... Due to bitterness we begin to point fingers at the evils with us.... Adam lanza, an honors student robbed his mother of four guns, killed her and most abominable of all: murdered twenty unarmed innocent children and six adults in cold blood....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Octavian's two biggest achievements

Octavian made himself a dictator and founded the principate which is system of monarchy which he headed for life with a strong military under his direct command (BBC).... The military was under the direct of Octavian and it followed that it was strengthened to reinforce the political will of Octavian as a dictator of Rome.... Thus, the removal of the barbarian threat abroad by the expeditionary campaign of his military paved the way for peace or Pax Romana, which is patently Octavian or Augustus Ceasar because of the legacy it created that we still enjoy today in the field of arts, culture and literature whereby it flourished due to the stability, good administration and unprecedented peace that prevailed during Octavian's rule....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan

In the paper “Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan” four issues will be tackled regarding the article Pulling Punches by Christopher Duncan: gender ideology, just parenting, good fathering, and Christian families as disciples who may be called to be “countercultural.... Am I a bad father for teaching him one, and not the other I hope not" (Duncan 2009, 1).... He may perceive he is being a bad parent if he does not clearly define gender roles-ultra-masculinity being demonstrated by the fact that his son would know how to fight....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

P J ORourkes Innocents Abroad Summary

The paper "P J O'Rourke's Innocents Abroad summary" states that the stereotyped attitudes come from propaganda and news that focuses us on the negative and ignores the majority not participating in that behavior.... The article points out the foolishness in judging everyone by a very narrow cultural baseline that is the American ethic.... hellip; The view that other cultures are bad dressers like the French, Japanese, and Saudis mentioned above is related to O'Rourke's opening comment that at least Americans understand English if spoken slowly and loudly enough....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Civil Disobedience

uestion #3 Injustice may be bad for the people but at the same time crucial to steer the government.... Through this, the government may learn the best ways to move the country to a better position in delivery to the people. Thoreau is giving a way in which one can decide to oppose the… Being in jail, taught Thoreau that the government was only able to control ones body and not the mind....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Mental Illness Problems in African American Youths

The article has got a number of researches to find the solution to the problem of mental illness.... The article has got several interviews undertaken to solve problems The paper “Mental Illness Problems in African American Youths by Choe Daniels, Stoddard and Zimmerman" is a brilliant version of an article on psychology.... The article has got a number of researches to find the solution to the problem of mental illness....
3 Pages (750 words) Article

Historical Perspectives on Family Studies by Stephanie Koontz

… The paper "Historical Perspectives on Family Studies by Stephanie Koontz" is a worthy example of an article review on social science.... The article, written by Stephanie Koontz, is a thought-provoking discourse which proffered complicated issues surrounding family studies.... The paper "Historical Perspectives on Family Studies by Stephanie Koontz" is a worthy example of an article review on social science.... he article, written by Stephanie Koontz, is a thought-provoking discourse which proffered complicated issues surrounding family studies....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

The Ancient Commentator of Plato and Aristotle by Miira Tuominen

… The paper "The Ancient Commentator of Plato and Aristotle by Miira Tuominen" is a perfect example of a philosophy article.... The paper "The Ancient Commentator of Plato and Aristotle by Miira Tuominen" is a perfect example of a philosophy article.... In reality, Aristotle like Plato held the view in the form of good in his Nicomachean Ethics.... With his views cemented in this belief that a form of good exists alongside judgment, Aristotle then concluded that morality is both theoretical and practical....
1 Pages (250 words) Article
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us