StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Relevance of Standard Costing and Variance Analysis - Report Example

Cite this document
Summary
This report "Relevance of Standard Costing and Variance Analysis" involves a critical analysis of the standard costing system and variance analysis in modern management. Due to the shift in cost structures and factory automation the process of standard costing…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.8% of users find it useful
Relevance of Standard Costing and Variance Analysis
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Relevance of Standard Costing and Variance Analysis"

?Relevance of Standard Costing & Variance Analysis Contents Contents 2 Introduction 3 Critical Analysis of Standard Costing & Variance Analysis 3 Conclusion 6 References 7 Bibliography 7 Introduction This project involves a critical analysis of the standard costing system and variance analysis in modern management. Due to shift in cost structures and factory automation the process of standard costing has been criticised due its declined relevance and contradiction with the modern manufacturing philosophy of JIT and continuous improvement. Critical Analysis of Standard Costing & Variance Analysis According to CIMA, standard costing is a technique to control costs by comparing the actual costs to the pre-set standards to obtain variances which facilitates in performance measurement (Walker, 2009, p.119). The standard cost is a predetermined unit cost i.e. the price and standard amount of each resource to be utilized in manufacturing a product and providing a service. A variance is the difference of actual cost incurred and expected standard cost. The variance analysis involves breakup of total variance to explain how much variance is caused by difference in use of resources from the standard usage quantity and how much variance is caused by the difference in prices of resources from the standard costs (Scarlett, 2008, p.96). The standard costing can be advantageous only if the cost standards are carefully established and prudently used. The use of standards solely for placing blame can have negative impact on management and employees. The major advantages include better management planning, promotes economy by making the employees understand importance of cost reduction, setting selling price, management control, highlights variances in management by exception and simplify the inventories’ costs reducing clerical costs (Weygandt, Kimmel & Kieso, 2009, p.495). Standard costing system was developed in accordance with the traditional manufacturing environment which has changed drastically in recent competitive environment. The critics of standard costing and variance analysis site the following reasons for its declining relevance: Changing Cost Structure: Provided that the standard costing is suited to the control of variable and direct costs but not fixed and indirect costs, the usefulness of standard costing has been questioned because the in recent times the overhead costs have become the relevant factory costs whereas the importance of direct labour costs has diminished. Inconsistency with JIT (Just-in-Time) Philosophy: JIT is an inventory system which works towards keeping zero inventories and reducing handling, warehousing and financing costs and time associated with tracking stocks and movements (Ajami & Goddard, 2006, p.357). This system has been widely adopted by American and European firms in the last decade. Although critics of standard costing and variance analysis assert that if performance of purchasing department is evaluated on the basis of purchase price variance then the purchase managers will be motivated to obtain materials at the lowest possible costs which can result in selection of many suppliers on the basis of lowest price, large quantity purchases resulting in larger inventories, low quality goods and indifference towards attainment of on-time delivery. This contradicts the JIT philosophy. Overemphasis on the importance of Direct Labour: The fact that direct labour has lost its importance in modern manufacturing and is a small proportion of the total factory costs, makes the standard costing irrelevant because most of the overhead costs are allocated to the cost centres on the basis of direct labour hours. To reduce their allocated costs the managers try to reduce the direct labour hours which diverts the attention from controlling the rising overhead costs. This is not an inadequacy of standard costing rather a faulty application of it to rely on volume variances to control short term costs and performance evaluation. Inconsistent with Continuous Improvement Philosophy: The standards in standard costing represent the targets to be achieved and maintained. This is highly inconsistent with the philosophy of continuous improvement. Delayed Feedback Reporting: The variance of performance reports arrive too late to be of any assistance in daily control of the production process (Smith, 2007, p.323-326). Robert S. Kaplan (1990) has noticed the influence of factory automation (FA) over use of standard costing and criticised saying that the goal of FA is to achieve zero human presence in factory which makes standard costing meaningless to use. Furthermore advanced technology has led to stable production process which otherwise used to be achieved by standard costing. As the product life cycle has shortened the standard-setting process for new products has become time consuming affair, for example it takes 2 months to set standard costs in a big automobile company. However standard costing is still used by some companies for two reasons as it still helps in reducing the production costs by 2-5% by effectively controlling costs at production stage and it makes easy to prepare financial statements due to easy computations involved. Although the method is not useful in controlling indirect labour (Kaplan, 1990, p.47). Many of these criticisms can be addressed by updating the standard costs regularly, use of demanding performance standards, segregated variance analysis, more focus on variance of variable overheads and quality costs than labour costs and real time information systems to immediately respond to reported variances (Scarlett, 2009, p.158). In the words of Drury the standards represent targets to be achieved rather than the philosophy of continuous improvement which requires the actual performance measures, not comparison with the standards to be reported periodically (Scarlett, 2009, p.158). However variance analysis does not seem to be incompatible with continuous improvement. It can be argued that it is the way in which the standards are traditionally formulated and maintained which has led to such a view as Drury’s. Conclusion The reasons stated by critics such as Kaplan and Drury for declined relevance of standard costing are changed cost structures, inconsistency with JIT and continuous improvement, delayed feedback towards reported variances and factory automation. However despite these shortcomings of standard costing many firms continue to use this system because of its simplicity to adopt and its effectiveness in reducing production costs. The shortcomings of standard costing have also been attributed to the way the cost standards have been formulated and maintained but not prudently used. These shortcomings can be mitigated by updating the standard costs regularly, use of demanding performance standards, segregated variance analysis, more focus on variance of variable overheads and quality costs than labour costs and real time information systems to immediately respond to reported variances. References Ajami, R.A. & Goddard, G.J. (2006). International business: theory and practice 2nd illustrated ed. M.E. Sharpe. Kaplan, R.S. (1990). Measures for manufacturing excellence. Harvard Business Press. Scarlett, R. (2008). CIMA Official Learning System Management Accounting - Performance Evaluation 5th ed. Elsevier. Scarlett, R. (2009). CIMA Official Learning System - Performance Operations 6th ed. Butterworth-Heinemann. Smith, J.A. (2007). Handbook of Management Accounting 4th illustrated ed. Elsevier. Walker, J. (2009). CIMA Official Learning System Fundamentals of Management Accounting 4th ed. Butterworth-Heinemann. Weygandt, J.J. Kimmel, P.D. & Kieso, D.E. (2009). Managerial Accounting: Tools for Business Decision Making 5th illustrated ed. John Wiley and Sons. Bibliography Cokins, G. (2001). Activity-based cost management: an executive's guide. John Wiley and Sons. Hilton, R.W. (2008). Managerial Accounting 7th ed. Tata McGraw-Hill Education. Weil, R.L. & Maher, M. (2005). Handbook of cost management 2nd illustrated ed. John Wiley and Sons. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Relevance of Standard Costing & Variance Analysis Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1440318--discuss-the-alleged-benefits-to-be-derived-from
(Relevance of Standard Costing & Variance Analysis Essay)
https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1440318--discuss-the-alleged-benefits-to-be-derived-from.
“Relevance of Standard Costing & Variance Analysis Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/finance-accounting/1440318--discuss-the-alleged-benefits-to-be-derived-from.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Relevance of Standard Costing and Variance Analysis

Financial managerment

Direct material cost and direct labour cost are allocated to the products in a similar way in both types of costing methods.... hellip; In Activity Based costing methodology, the overhead costs are accumulated and assigned to the activities of the production and non-production departments.... 141 132 (685) TASK 2: Traditional Full costing: Full costing is defined as a method of costing of products in which all the manufacturing costs are included in the cost of the products being manufactured....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Standard Costs for Product Costing

Although a small-scale manufacturer, the management has identified the benefits of standard costing and plans to implement the system.... (Michael, 2011) Despite of these benefits, literature claims that shorter life cycles of products, new advanced manufacturing technologies, lesser importance of labor in the manufacturing process, and globalized competition has potential to cause expiration of standard costing (Sulaiman et al.... A significant addition to the debate whether to encourage the use of standard costing is the research by Zoysa et al, in 2007....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Relevance of Standard Costing & Variance Analysis

This paper, relevance of standard costing & Variance Analysis, presents standard costing which is a technique to control costs by comparing the actual costs to the pre-set standards to obtain variances which facilitates in performance measurement.... hellip; This project involves a critical analysis of the standard costing system and variance analysis in modern management.... Due to shift in cost structures and factory automation the process of standard costing has been criticised due its declined relevance and contradiction with the modern manufacturing philosophy of JIT and continuous improvement....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

What Is Variance Analysis

This paper "What Is variance analysis?... nbsp; … The variance analysis also assists the managers in rewarding efficient and effective performance of the labour force of the manufacturing concern.... nbsp;   But it is of prime importance that management; especially the supervisors acquire full explanations of the reasons for these variances otherwise such variance analysis would be no good for control purposes.... "What is variance analysis?...
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Analysis of Various Costing Techniques and Assessment of Their Applicability

Such methods which help in analysing costs are known as variance analysis helps to determine variation from standards and in turn enhances productivity (Thukkaram, 2007).... The paper is an analysis of traditional and modern methods of costing and also, lays down an explanation for each one of these methods, besides recognising the importance of each one in specific industries.... The prime objective of the paper is to understand the different methods of costing and analyse and establish the method of costing which is indispensable as per the kind of organizational setting and organizational needs in context....
12 Pages (3000 words) Research Paper

Management accounting

The ideas behind ABC are: Both traditional absorption costing and activity base costing systems adopt the two-stage allocation process.... Labour efficiency variance was adverse because maybe there was lost time in excess of standard allowed or output was lower than standard set due to lack of training and sub-standard materials.... 0while the adverse sales volume variance may be articulated to unexpected fall in demand or production difficulties....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Costing Techniques Benefits for JetBlue

The paper begins with a brief analysis of JetBlue's background, their span of operations and their general strategies to success.... The project tries to identify how the company can benefit by incorporating diverse costing strategies to give effect to better decision… costing techniques facilitates the organization to utilize such financial resources more optimally.... costing techniques are essentially not reflected in a company annual reports or financial statements....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

Strategic Management Accounting: Manac Plc

It is essential to note that standards are a major part of standard costing and companies might use standards in the business without implementing standard costing systems.... In short, the process of standard costing is where the quantities of the inputs can be clearly obtained based on factors like the ideal performance, or also on the expected performance.... it can is better if the company does not adopt the standard costing method of accounting and uses the Variances analysis instead....
12 Pages (3000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us