StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from M. L. King, Jr - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research is being carried out to present argument analysis of a letter from eight white clergymen and letter from Birmingham Jail by Martin Luther King, Jr. Upon close review and evaluation, both letters conform to the ethical code of standards expected of their profession…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.9% of users find it useful
A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from M. L. King, Jr
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from M. L. King, Jr"

Argument Analysis: A Call For Unity: A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from Birmingham Jail by Martin Luther King, Jr. Rhetorical Situation The exigence defines what prompted the authors to write the letters in the first place. For A Call for Unity written by the eight white clergymen, the exigence was the series of demonstrations held by Negro citizens that were allegedly led and directed by outsiders. In the case of King’s letter, the exigence was the need to respond to the clergymen’s contentions that as the outsider being mentioned, his actions were deemed unwise and untimely. The audiences were supposedly the local community and readers of the Birmingham, Alabama newspaper since the first letter were sent to its editor. However, one could surmise that the letter was, in fact, directed to King, as the noted leader of the civil rights movement, in behalf of the Negro community. King’s letter was directed to the clergymen, as most of his arguments addressed the clergymen’s position. The most obvious constraint was on the part of King who was incarcerated in the Birmingham jail during the time that he responded to the clergymen’s allegations. On the part of the clergymen’s letter, the constraints are their maintaining a conservative stance to use the most appropriate language so as not to project any biases to both white and Negro citizenry. Summary of Issues from the Two Points of Views The basic issue presented by the clergymen was the appeal for law, order and common sense in addressing the dilemma on racism. The basis position was for any resentment on alleged discriminations and racial slur should be filed in the proper court of law where legal proceedings and verdict should be respected and accepted. The clergymen contended that the series of demonstrations by Negro citizens were actually led and directed by outsiders, whose actions were deemed unwise and untimely. Finally, the letter highlighted the call for restraint, “for law enforcement officials to remain calm and to continue to protect our city from violence” (Carpenter, et al. 182). On the other hand, King’s basic issued focused on responding to the clergymen’s assertion that his leading the Negro citizens into demonstrations were unwise and untimely. King addressed this argument by initially proving that he was not an outsider; but that he was invited to address the injustices in Birmingham. Further, his letter addressed the clergymen’s position regarding his unwise action towards demonstration; revealed that action was necessary because promises by merchants were broken and that the need for direct-action versus negotiation was favored due to the community’s stance of refusal to negotiate. In terms of responding to the untimely issues, King expounded on concerns such as: the new administration must be prodded and that the Negro citizens have already waited for 340 years (King 186). Analysis The letter of the clergymen was more direct and concise containing only seven paragraphs. King’s response was comprehensively detailed and lengthy encompassing 50 paragraphs and 14 pages. King was clear in addressing the issues of the clergymen indicating his actions as the leader of the demonstrations as unwise and untimely. He warrants that the non-violent actions were the most appropriate means to address the racial discrimination in Birmingham and their actions could not be considered unwise because a rational four step process was applied: “collection of the facts to determine whether injustices exist; negotiation; self-purification; and direct action” (King 184). The issue of untimeliness was responded to by King as he emphasized the need to prod the new administration to create some tension and lead them to act. Further, he argued that the Negro citizens have waited for too long for more than 340 years and could therefore not be considered that no time was spent to reflect and think of the course of action. King warrants that the present laws were actually unjust and expounded on a differentiation between just and unjust law where “any law that degrades human personality is unjust” (King 188). This assertion was supported by disclosing that “all segregation statues are unjust because segregation distorts the soul and damages the personality” (King 188). The clergymen asserted that their actions, although non-violent must be condemned for precipitating violent actions. Through the use of effective analogies (robbed man and his possessions; Socrates and his unwavering commitment to truth; and Jesus being crucified because of his devotion to God) King warrants that the clergymen’s arguments were illogical. He backed his declarations by concluding that their non-violent actions should actually be commended for this is the most effective means to gain their equal constitutional rights. Fallacies and Rebuttals One of the fallacies exposed by King was the clergymen’s misconception of time in proposing that “All Christians know that colored people will receive equal rights eventually…” (King 190). The white moderate men who argued this was rebutted by King when he indicated that “time itself is neutral; it can be used either destructively or constructively” (King 190). In so doing, King defended that their non-violent actions were done in acknowledgement of the right time as justice could not wait to see Negroes being continually discriminated and prejudiced. Another fallacy exposed was the teaching of the church’s religious leaders who seem to promote desegregation but in truth, their actions revealed that “those are social issues with which the gospel has no real concern” (King 193). King’s rebuttal focused on the church stance to be silent and not to disturb the status quo. He acknowledged that “if today’s church does not recapture its sacrificial spirit… it will lose its authenticity, forfeit the loyalty of millions and be dismissed as an irrelevant social club with no meaning” (King 194). Ethical and Unethical Qualities Upon close review and evaluation, both letters conform to the ethical code of standards expected of their profession. Both letters were written by religious leaders, including King, who wrote in the capacity of the President of Southern Christian Leadership Conference. Actually, King’s introductory remarks validated his respect as he wrote: “My Dear Fellow Clergymen” (King 183). Conclusion After reviewing and analyzing both letters in great detail, one is convinced that the letter of King was far effective in gaining the emotional, logical and ethical appeal of readers, and particularly of the addressee. The effectiveness was gauged in terms of King’s appropriate use of language, argumentative support, rebuttals and by disputing fallacies and unsubstantiated contentions. He had addressed all the issues and concerns delivered by the clergymen with clear support of logical reasoning and critical thinking. In the end, his concluding remarks noted a unifying invitation to see the issues not from within divisive perspectives, but, in his own words: “as a fellow clergyman and a Christian brother” (King 197) that clearly and effectively answered the clergymen’s call for unity. Works Cited Carpenter, CCJ and et al. "A Call for Unity: A Letter from Eight White Clergymen." Chapter 8: Writing the Argument Analysis Paper: Review and Synthesis. n.d. 181-183. King, Martin Luther Jr. "Letter in Birmingham Jail." Chapter 8: Writing the Argument Analysis Paper: Review and Synthesis. n.d. 183 - 197. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from M. L. King, Jr Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1433802-letter-from-eight-white-clergymen-and-letter-from-birmingham-jail-by-martin-luther-king-jr
(A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from M. L. King, Jr Essay)
https://studentshare.org/english/1433802-letter-from-eight-white-clergymen-and-letter-from-birmingham-jail-by-martin-luther-king-jr.
“A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from M. L. King, Jr Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1433802-letter-from-eight-white-clergymen-and-letter-from-birmingham-jail-by-martin-luther-king-jr.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF A Letter From Eight White Clergymen and Letter from M. L. King, Jr

Letter From a Birmingham Jail

In the letter from a Birmingham Jail written by Martin Luther King, Jr.... … Name Instructor's Name Course Date Argumentative Essay: letter from a Birmingham Jail In the letter from a Birmingham Jail written by Martin Luther King, Jr.... Argumentative Essay: letter from a Birmingham Jail In the letter from a Birmingham Jail written by Martin Luther King, Jr.... The letter was addressed to fellow clergymen and was written in response to a supposed remark that classified Martin Luther King's (MLK) activities as allegedly untimely and unwise....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Eight Alabama Clergymen's Public Statement to Martin Luther King

It was written by a group of white clergymen from Birmingham in 1963.... It was written by a group of white clergymen from Birmingham in 1963.... Name: University: Course: Tutor: Date: “Eight Alabama Clergymen's Public Statement to Martin Luther King, jr.... ?? Quotation Essay The analyzed quotation is part of “Eight Alabama Clergymen's Public Statement to Martin Luther King, jr.... “Eight Alabama Clergymen's Public ment to Martin Luther King, jr....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Assignment argumentative

Name Instructor Course Date Critical Analysis of letter from Birmingham Jail letter from Birmingham Jail is a controversial letter by Martin Luther King which was drafted in 1963 as a result of racial inequality.... The main argument in letter from Birmingham was that injustice has both direct and indirect effects on the public, and direct action was needed.... letter from Birmingham Jail was to prove that grassroots action against racism was not as radical as the government and some clergymen perceived it to be....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

The Letter From Birmingham Jail

Martin Luther king jr.... The paper "The letter from Birmingham Jail" states that letter has a powerful conclusion where he contends that the human personality and soul is damaged through segregation, which he has addressed throughout the letter.... King decided to author letter from Birmingham Jail where he seeks to justify why direct and non-violent action is necessary, writing the letter as an answer to the white clergymen.... his article is titled letter from Birmingham Jail; while its thesis statement is that, the black people must be allowed to demonstrate at that time because it was necessary to do so....
4 Pages (1000 words) Literature review

Martin Luther King Jr.'s Letter from Birmingham Jail

Luther king jr.... Martin Luther king jr.... Though Luther king jr.... Martin Luther king jr.... In his long letter king jr.... s letter from Birmingham Jail was not only the most vocal expression against the social and religious cruelties such as oppressions, deprivations, injustice on the black people inflicted by the white, but it also sent out a very significant and strong message… the clergymen, whom it was sent to, that black people were no more to suffer these evils of humiliating racial repression, on the contrary, they will make their mark by prolonged struggle with non violence as their strongest weapon....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Rhetorical analysis of Martin Luther King's letter from Birmingham Jail

Also known as The Negro is Your Brother and letter from Birmingham City Jail, The Letter from Birmingham Jail is an open letter that Martin Luther King Jr.... Martin Luther king jr.... King also defends the use of nonviolent resistance to racism, on the account that people have moral authority and The success of The letter from Birmingham Jail is underscored by it becoming a key text for the United States civil rights movement of the 1960s.... (January 15, 1929- April 4, 1968) was a civil rights activist, American… In the letter, king defends the use of non-violent resistance to racial segregation and discrimination....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Letter From Birmingham Jail

His letter was a Analysis of Letter from Birmingham Jail Martin Luther king jr.... The Liberatory Thought of Martin Luther king jr: Critical Essays on the Philosopher King.... “Instrumental and Constitutive Rhetoric in Martin Luther king jr.... Eight White Religious Leaders, and the "letter from Birmingham Jail.... letter from the Birmingham Jail.... s ‘letter from Birmingham Jail.... letter from Birmingham Jail and the Struggle That Changed a Nation....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

American Crisis from Martin Luther King Jr. Words

The paper "American Crisis from Martin Luther king jr.... Martin Luther king jr.... In this paper, I am going to discuss the non-violent tactics that Martin Luther king jr advocated to respond to the violence of political order and reasons for advocating for such tactics.... eing a clergyman, Martin Luther king jr advocated for the philosophy of non-violence in order to end racial segregation and discrimination in America.... In his letter from Birmingham, he relies much on biblical allusion that stresses love to all, including the enemies....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us