StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Most people would agree that schools should have the freedom to decide what kind of ethos and style they wish their staff and students to represent. Some schools have very strict rules, with mandatory uniforms, while others advocate a free dress code. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory"

Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory Most people would agree that schools should have the freedom to decide what kind of ethos and style they wish their staff and students to represent. Some schools have very strict rules, with mandatory uniforms, while others advocate a free dress code. The question of whether or not to introduce mandatory school uniforms has been widely debated with a wide range of opinions being expressed in the United States in recent years. Arguments against and for this policy are therefore considered in the light of some recent studies of this issue.

This paper proposes that school uniforms should be mandatory because they foster team spirit and self- respect in a culture which too often promotes selfish individualism and rebellion. One of the most common arguments cited against the use of mandatory school uniforms is that of the right of the individual to freedom of expression. This right is guaranteed in the First Amendment (Isaacson, 1998, p. 1) and is designed to allow equal opportunities for people who have different cultures, religions, and personal convictions to distinguish themselves.

It is argued that school uniforms can impose one particular style upon students, and that this is not fair to those who come from a minority group which does not share the beliefs and taste of the dominant group. Other criticisms include the study Brunsma which reviews over 100 articles on the topic of school uniform policy and concludes that mandatory school uniforms have no clear benefit for schools or students and may in fact encourage both students and parents to feel excluded from key school policies and decisions.

(Brunsma, p. 186) Any perceptions that uniforms encourage safer schools with better academic achievement is written off as a “halo effect” which has more to do with perception than reality. (Brunsma, p. 36) Factors like the inability of poorer families to afford expensive uniforms, and the ability of non-uniform items like backpacks, shoes and technology items to create social differences within the school environment are also mentioned in arguments against mandatory school uniform policies.

An important study by Cohn has shown that when mandatory uniform codes were introduced in Long Beach, there was an immediate and positive result on many performance markers, including reductions in suspensions (by 32%), school crime (by 36 %), fighting (by 51 %), and vandalism (by 18%). (Cohn, 1996). This evidence shows that the introduction of school uniforms influences the whole culture of a school, and reduces negative behaviors by a considerable amount. The objections relating to the different abilities of students and their families to pay for expensive school uniforms are valid and they need to be considered by school authorities when introducing a mandatory policy.

It is important here to distinguish between the principle of mandatory uniforms, and the practicalities of implementation. If the principle is good, but unaffordable in some cases, then the correct procedure is to deal with the affordability issues in order to enable all students to participate equally in the uniform policy. So for example reduced cost uniforms, subsidized sales mechanisms, and a moderate cost outlay are mechanisms that can be used to keep the uniforms within the reach of all students and their families.

Families need to provide clothes in any event, and so a competitively priced and reasonable selection of goods which conform to the policy can actually help less wealthy families to manage their budgets. It makes no sense to throw out the principle of mandatory uniform, and all the benefits that go with it, when the practical objections can be so easily overcome with a little forward planning. The first amendment objections are often used as a cover for deeper concerns about dominant ideologies and the suppression of individuality.

The truth is that mandatory uniforms set students on an equal footing, within a regulated and hierarchical system in which students learn both to conform to group norms, and to develop confidence in individual expression. Students have multiple opportunities in the classroom and in their lives outside school, to develop individuality as often as they wish. Opportunities to develop team spirit and acceptance of corporate responsibility are much rarer, especially for teenagers. Mandatory uniforms help to create a positive team spirit, and a collective identity which in turn influences behaviour for the better.

In conclusion , therefore , the introduction of mandatory school uniforms has proved to be both popular and successful in many districts of modern America. The most common objections can be overcome with consultation and goodwill, offering support for those who find practical difficulties in meeting the demands of the policy. References Brunsma, D.L. (2004 ) The School Uniform Movement and What it Tells us About American Education: A Symbolic Crusade. Maryland: ScarecrowEducation. Cohn, C.A. (1996) Mandatory School Uniforms.

The School Administrator 53 (2), 22-25. Isaacson, L.A. (1998) Student Dress Code. Eric Digest 117, pp. 1-5. Available online at: https://scholarsbank.uoregon.edu/xmlui/bitstream/handle/1794/3340/digest117.pdf?sequence=1

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory Research Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1425952-why-school-uniforms-should-be-mandatory
(Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory Research Paper)
https://studentshare.org/english/1425952-why-school-uniforms-should-be-mandatory.
“Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory Research Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1425952-why-school-uniforms-should-be-mandatory.
  • Cited: 3 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why School Uniforms Should Be Mandatory

School Uniforms for American Public Schools

Wearing of school uniforms should be made mandatory in all of the American public schools.... Assuming you have two students, one wearing a uniform and the other in civilian clothes, it is only evident that the uniformed student may be denied access to prohibited areas for minors such as bars and they would indeed attract a lot of attention from the public if they are noted as trying to solicit for such pleasures during time which they should be in school.... Assuming you have two students, one wearing a uniform and the other in civilian clothes, it is only evident that the uniformed student may be denied access to prohibited areas for minors such as bars and they would indeed attract a lot of attention from the public if they are noted as trying to solicit for such pleasures during time which they should be in school....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Editorial article on school uniform

Despite this, some people are strongly against the students wearing school uniforms.... This was after one year of adopting mandatory school uniforms.... Consequently, President Clinton visited the school in 1995 where he urged other schools to also consider adopting the mandatory school uniforms.... Clinton said, “ if school uniform will make our children to stop killing each other over designer jackets, it is then crucial for schools to require their students wear school uniforms” (Wilkins 5)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Should school uniforms be mandatory

Some schools allow students to use the color dresses at least once Many people believe that the school uniforms must be implemented strictly in schools in order to avoid any negative feelings among children.... I am an advocate of the strict adherence of school uniforms in school campus and this paper analyses various factors in favor and against the implementation of school uniforms.... One of the major arguments in favor of school uniforms is related to safety and security of the students....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Should school uniforms be mandatory

This paper will specifically discuss why school uniforms are required and what kind of critical comments are made in the wake of not wearing them by the students.... What this suggests is the fact that school uniforms bring in the much needed uniformity that the school would like to inculcate within the students.... The school authorities are always on the look… school uniforms have also received a great amount of criticism as one would believe....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Should Students Wear Uniforms to School

Bowen (2014) argues that students should be allowed to make their own choices despite the school uniform policies.... The paper "Should Students Wear Uniforms to School " states that most countries have policies in place regarding school uniforms and by considering the advantages of having students wear school uniforms to school, it is quite clear that uniforms are necessary for schools.... hellip; It has been established that school uniforms save parents time and money....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

School uniforms

Proponents of the adoption of school uniforms in public schools emphasize the importance of these outfits.... They relate the uniforms to specific academic outcomes and behaviors amongst not just students but… Critics have claimed that school uniforms have impacts on neither academic performance nor behavior of students both at school and in their homes.... They claim that uniform policies may have adverse effects on student outcomes and Traditionally, school uniforms were meant for the private sector and it is only recently that a viable policy was introduced for uniforms in public schools in the United States of America....
13 Pages (3250 words) Research Paper

Your choice

The reasons why school uniforms should be encouraged are various.... One of the reasons why school uniforms should be made a requirement in schools is that school uniforms build a homogeneous environment amongst students, reducing peer pressure and cases of bullying.... School uniform in learning institutions is an issue that can bring numerous discussions on whether they should be made mandatory or not in schools.... Students in schools should wear school uniforms as it creates a learning environment and also prevents instances The benefits that accrue to all the stakeholders of the school when students wear school uniforms provide an excellent basis and rationale as to why all students in all schools should wear school uniforms....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Role of School Uniforms in Public Schools

Public schools requiring their students to wear uniforms aids in the elimination of gangs, school violence, bullying, and peer pressure, making it easy to identify intruders, and in the end, the school administration, parents, and student bodies can manage the students effectively.... nbsp; In this respect, unification of school uniform may serve as an appropriate way for mastering of pupils' management from the perspective of a great many negative aspects caused by schoolchildren's liberty of expression through clothing....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us