Comparing the Scarlet Letter & the Crucible

Comparing the Scarlet Letter & & the Crucible

Throughout the history of American Literature, there have been several stories that have had their share of debate. Although I’m fairly particular that most people needed to check out both books that I’m going to be discussing in high school, there are couple of people who have had a chance to sit down and really explore how they share similar styles. Through cautious analysis of The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthrone and The Crucible by Arthur Miller; you can see the proof that supports the truth that both of these 2 works are rather associated. These styles include sin, punishment of sin, the devil, and love/lust.

The most apparent theme contained in both works is sin. In The Scarlet Letter, the sin that has actually been dedicated is adultery and has actually produced an illegitimate child. Hester Prynne, and the outspoken and praised minister of the Puritan community Arthur Dimmsdale were the adulters who committed the sin and produced the child Pearl. Throughout the story Hester is dehumanized for her sin, while Dimmsdale is still thought to be the “almighty” minister. In similarity, from The Crucible, sin is put on trial. The book directly resolves the styles and concepts from Salem Witch Trials.

The girls and their “leader” Abigail are the core of sin and evil in the women and the community. Throughout the story accusations are “thrown” at others from the community who are believed righteous. Ultimately in this story the sin is “coming” directly from the black-man or the devil. The women are believed to have actually formed a pact with the devil and are now trying to lure others to come with them. Overall, in both works, sin and how sin impacts the lives of individuals and their neighborhoods is the recurring theme. The scaffold in The Scarlet Letter is exceptionally important.

The most critical scenes in the book happen on it. The scaffold is a place of public humiliation. The crook must stand in front of all his or her peers with them totally knowing of his/her crime. Basing on the scaffold as a guilty sinner would also imply that they would be avoided, as Hester was, for the rest of their lives. It seems an awful penalty by today’s standards; however the scaffold was not simply a terrible gadget of embarrassment and reject. The scaffold was the society’s method of righting a wrong and preventing it from being duplicated. The whole town repented to see

Hester, among their own standing in front of them for a horrendous criminal offense. It reinforced their resolve to continue to do what in their minds was exemplary. The scaffold was not only a place of penalty. It was a location of satisfaction as well. It offered the guilty person relief understanding that they were acknowledged as a sinner and that they did not need to deal with the prison and the regret of their minds anymore. The distinction between Hester’s emotional state and Dimmesdale’s state was huge. Hester was a recognized crook, she felt that she had actually been unished and was continually punished by the “A.” Dimmesdale, nevertheless, never went through penalty before his peers, so his guilt, his prison, festered inside him until he began to physically degrade. His lack of peace from hiding from the scaffold, from fact, was his undoing. As Dimmesdale found out at the very end of his life, the scaffold was every guilty Puritan’s only way of redemption. Chillingworth himself said, “Hast thou sought the entire earth over … there was no location so secret, no high location nor lowly location, where thou couldst have actually escaped me, save money on this very scaffold! “

The forest beyond Salem was unknown country, liking that of hell or the world of the devil. It was where the feared “Black Man” was fabled to meet with witches and sinners. The forest was likewise far from Salem, its spying eyes and severe judgements. Here occasions might be open and totally free. Here was the only place where Hester and Dimmesdale can fulfill and talk easily of the sin they shared seven years previously. In this respect the Puritans were precise in their superstitious notion of the Black Man living in the forest. There was indeed in the forest a place where complimentary thinking could go unfettered by Puritan code.

This “Black Guy” was no more than the liberty to form concepts beyond the Puritan lifestyle. It threatened to Hester and Arthur as they conspired to flee the nest instead of facing their issue. Girlfriend Hibbins acknowledged the change in Dimmesdale and acknowledged that he has had un-Puritan concepts. So he had, in a sense, consulted with the Black Man. The forest, at its a lot of basic level was merely that place in the Puritan mind that non-conforming Puritan thoughts caould go into. The forest is not only a crucial area for meeting of “sinners” but also conjuring of spirts and welcoming the devil.

As seen in The Crucible the women “satisfied” with and conjured the spirits of the devil and the underworld. This was a meeting point of the mortal world which of the dead. In both works the forest, or other darkened place, signifies a wicked realm that just couple of get in, and never return from. Love versus desire is a characteristic that is expressed through the relationships in between several protagonist in both works. From The Scarlet Letter, the illegitimate and improper relationship in between Hester and Dimmsdale was the most visible.

Their love for each other extends far beyond a mere “crush” or aching to be with the person, for they have actually consummated a relationship together which ended with the birth of the daughter Pearl. Throughout the book Dimmsdale had outside expressions of love for his child Pearl and her mom Hester, “Pearl kissed his lips. A spell was broken. The great scene of sorrow, in which …” (233) reveals the fondness of Dimmsdale for his daughter Pearl. Nevertheless, in The Crucible, such types of relationships are not evident. The only relationship in the story happened in between John Proctor and Abigail.

Pertinent Subjects Readers Likewise Choose

  • Quotes about Chillingworth

This “relationship” was more of a crush and lusting by Abigail than a real relationship of love as that of Hester and Dimmsdale. Proctor and Abigail have simply been in a “relationship” without the understanding of Goody Proctor, John’s other half, nor the knowledge of the other townspeople. Proctor ends up being identified that his affair with Abigail will not continue, “… I will no longer come for you.” (77) Relationships in both works were not the main focus of the stories, although they appeared, and both were not proper in the Puritan society of the time. Both were frequently penalized by death or ublic humiliation such as that of Hester Prynne. After a complete analysis of such themes of The Scarlet Letter and The Crucible, you would be able to much better understand the viewpoints of both authors, Hawthorne and Miller. Likewise you can pick up the fact that such themes were prevalent throughout numerous works which have actually been written handling such eras in history. Sin, guilt, love, lust, and the devil have actually always existed in the minds and the lives of authors and readers, and always will; thus causing the creation of gripping works of literature to prize for several years to come.

You Might Also Like