Comparative Essay- to Eliminate a Mockingbird and the Lamp at Twelve noon
Alexander Navracic/Takayuki Suzuki Navracic, Suzuki 1 Devin Mason ENG3U December 26, 2012 A Comparative Essay: “To Eliminate a Mockingbird” and “The Lamp at Midday”? “To Eliminate a Mockingbird” is a novel by Harper Lee, told by Jean Louise Finch whose nickname is Scout. She is a young girl from Alabama who lives in small city called Maycomb with her older bro Jem and dad Atticus. She explains bigotry against blacks, particularly Tom Robinson. On the other hand, the brief fiction “The Light at Noon” by Sinclair Ross narrates the story about farmer Paul and his partner Ellen.
They argue about staying or moving from the farm because of a dust storm. Both works are related with essential occasions in U. S.? s history. “To Eliminate a Mockingbird” describes the U. S.? s society after Civil War and “The Light at Twelve noon” happens during the Great Anxiety. There are many similarities and differences between these 2 operate in regards to themes linked to gender discrimination, empathy and sacrifice. (AN+TS)? To start, in “To Kill a Mockingbird” and “The Lamp at Twelve noon” one common style is gender discrimination. For instance, Scout thinks that being called a woman is the worst thing possible.
She hangs out with boys and fights which symbolizes that she is a gamine. Aunt Alexandra does not like that and attempts to make a woman from her. Scout tells, “Auntie Alexandra? s vision of my deportment involved playing with small stoves, tea sets, and using the Add-A-Pearl locket she provided me when I was born; […]” (108 ). Next, the discrimination against women was seen also during Reverend Sykes? s preachings. He discusses ladies? s pollutant and warns his people against them. He says, “Bootledggers triggered enough Navracic, Suzuki 2 problem in the Quarters, however females are even worse. To an audience in church]” (162) In addition, the gender discrimination against males is considerable in that unique, too. To demonstrate, Francis is proud that granny is going to teach him how to prepare, however Scout is condescending him and all men at the exact same time. “Boys wear? t cook.” (109) Likewise, in “The Light at Noon” Paul discriminates Ellen when she wants to relocate to the town where her daddy lives. Paul says, “You are farmer? s wife now. [To Ellen]” (66) He reveals that her location is on the farm with him because she picked to be his spouse. Her bligation is to be great, loyal wife who will be with him in good times as well as in bad times as she as soon as assured. He is head of the family and her role is to look after house and their child. In both works females are condescended by men. In a different way, in “To Eliminate a Mockingbird” one can find reversible gender discrimination while in “The Light at Midday” is just discrimination versus women. (AN)? In addition, other typical style of these 2 works is compassion, also called walking in another person? s shoes. For instance, Atticus is empathic person.
Prior to he makes some conclusion or viewpoint on somebody, he enjoys on particular issue from their point of view. On that concept he raises up his kids. When Scout goes to school the very first day she gets home annoyed that she does not want to go to school again since of Miss Caroline. Atticus immediately empathizes with Miss Caroline and explains Scout her situation. He states, “You never actually understand an individual till you think about things from his point of view? [To Search]” (39) On the other hand, Paul and Ellen are unable to feel sorry for each other due to the fact that of the dust storm.
Paul over rakes the land, ruining the roots which results in desertification. They lose their infant, their relationship remains in crisis, and all this takes place since Paul is oblivious and does not listen to his wife who cautioned him and pleaded him for compassion. She states to Paul, “Think about me– and him. It? s unfair. We have our lives, too, to Navracic, Suzuki 3 live. […]” (66) At the starting they argue however at the end compromise comes, she guarantees to stay and he will grow fibrous crops. Finally, empathy and compromise are essential in relationships, society and daily living. (AN)??