Critic Jonathan Baumbach explores the significance of innocence in J.D Salinger’s Catcher in the Rye. He declares that the book is not only about innocence, but actively for innocence-as if keeping one’s childness were an existing possibility. Not only that, but he mentions that Holden wants to be a saint: the protector and savior of innocence by preventing them from falling under the harsh adult world of corruption and fickleness. Although he likewise desires somebody to prevent his own fall since he is in fact still a child himself.
Baumbach specifies that this is Holden’s paradox, saying that he must shed his own innocence to secure innocence. These statements are what send Holden off into the 3 day soul-searching mission that dooms Holden to sinking into madness in our novel.
The critic opens with a rather detailed insight about how others see and review Salinger’s first and just novel, along with pointing a few of the flaws that Catcher has: “The novel is emotional; it loads the deck for Holden and against the adult world, the little but corrupt group that Holden encounters is not representative adequate to allow Salinger his inclusive judgments about the types.
” Baumbach declares that Holden does not have adequate details to discuss the phoniness of humanity as an entire based on his observations of only a choose few.
As the critic examines even more, he makes a few intriguing points. Some of which regard Mr. Antolini: Holden’s former English teacher. Baumbach declares that Antolini’s generosity to Holden is set off by a homosexual interest that he has in the lead character. Pointing out the flaws in his instructors marriage, along with unclear actions that he had actually done while with Caulfield. Based upon Baumbach’s misguided interpretation the reader could be resulted in think that of Mr. Antolini’s gesture as one of a perverted old male rather than as one of worried mentor.
Additionally, the critic proceeds to go over Holden’s issue of where the ducks go throughout the winter season. He declares that what Holden really would like to know is whether there is a good-hearted authority that takes care of the ducks; for if there is one for the ducks, there is need to be one for individuals as well. Next, Baumbach switches focus to Holden’s prayer to Allie, which occurs prior to he goes to visit his household’s house. The critic postulates that Holden’s prayer to Allie is not a lot an act of suffering as an act of love. However, if one carefully examines the scene in the novel, the reader will realize that Holden’s prayer is actually the act of one wallowing in self-pity, of one that has really hit rock bottom.
After analyzing Jonathan Baumbach’s review I can collect that he is a fantastic writer, he uses a vibrant vocabulary and his sentences are completely structured. Although a line should be drawn when utilizing more complicated vocabulary; for while checking out the critique the reader will likely find themselves needing to search for several words to comprehend the points the critic is attempting get across. Not only that, but the critic makes numerous presumptions based on very little information or goes out on a limb to make a point. Moreover, Baumbach’s points concerning Mr. Antolini’s homosexual nature, the significance of the Central Park ducks, in addition to Holden’s prayer to Allie are not completely concrete, and leave themselves open for conflict.
When a reader goes through a book more than when, they discover things they never ever captured while reading it through the first time. One would recognize that Holden views Mr. Antolini as a father figure and a good example and concerns him trying to find all the answers to the concerns nobody has actually figured out yet. For instance, throughout the story when Holden comes to Mr. Antolini’s apartment, He understands that Holden is spiraling downward and is basically aiming to fall under that madness he has been drifting towards throughout the novel, he alerts him of this and ultimately the 2 head to sleep. Now the questionable action that triggers some of the audience to think that Mr. Antolini is sexually interested in Caulfied, is that he awoke to discover him stroking his hair.
Holden misconstrued and made such a rash decision to put everyone into that Bogus corrupt personality that he believes humankind is composed of, and storms off out of his house. If Holden was thinking more plainly he would’ve probably had the ability to handle the circumstance more properly, realizing that Antolini was just stroking his hair in more of a worried fatherly method. The reader can inform by the method Holden refers to Mr. Antolini they have a strong relationship and he sees him as a surrogate daddy, and not some perverted old guy that Baumbach has actually painted him out to be.
In addition, As far as the Central Park ducks are concerned … Holden’s compulsive interest about what happens to the ducks during the winter reveals the more child-like side to his character. Although Baumbach thinks that Holden is looking for a higher power, instead helps him relate to that child innocence he is so keen on. It gives him the hope that change isn’t always long-term. It also helps the reader compare Holden’s ideal world in which time stalls (Like in the Museum of Natural History), to the real life which is constantly changing. Proving that he isn’t looking for some sort of “higher power” in the ducks, however it was a way to correspond with his innocence of his childhood.
Finally, when Holden strikes rock bottom in the unique he states a prayer to Allie, in which Baumbach declares that it is an act of love and distress. Although, this isn’t entirely true. Holden is actually indulging his own self-pity, how could he hope to Allie for assistance when while Allie lived he would not even enable him to go on his bike with him and a buddy? Sure, he feels regret for it now that he is dead and no longer with him, however it occurred yet once again when Phoebe wanted to run away with him and Caulfied turned her down the same as he had made with Allie. Proving that after hitting rock bottom Holden is desperate enough to pray although he doesn’t actually think in God, however is hoping that there is one to not only conserve him however the soul of his departed brother too.
In conclusion, Baumbach as a critic did write a well-written evaluation of J.D Salinger’s Catcher in the Rye although it was a bit tough to understand at times, he made a clear point and backed up his point with facts from the book. He had colorful vocabulary and his review flowed well together. Although the critique was a bit on the longer side I did delight in reading it. The Catcher in the Rye which is believed to be J.D Salinger’s most popular work, had actually been an everlasting favorite of teens and tweens of the literary scene. This novel known for its elegant prose and focus on styles of angst, alienation, and disobedience has received large praise for its extraordinary sense of originality. This book will withstand as a life time favorite of teenage years all over since it has life and is most likely the most initial piece of its time.