StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Issue of Transsexual Marriage in Hong Kongs State Law - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
"The Issue of Transsexual Marriage in Hong Kong’s State Law" paper analyzes the case which case takes into consideration the implication of the verdict on the social spectrum of the transsexual with regards to his/her legal rights as a spouse, especially in immigration. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.1% of users find it useful
The Issue of Transsexual Marriage in Hong Kongs State Law
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Issue of Transsexual Marriage in Hong Kongs State Law"

W & Registrar of Marriages Hong Kong’s law making body had its nail biting observation of a trial at the court over the issue of transsexual marriage crises recently. While post operative male-to-female transsexual man’s or female-to-male transsexual woman’s issue has been treated on par with the constitutional provisions which determines that anatomically altered sexuality of a person does not constitute to legitimate sexuality with entitlement of marital rights according to the laws in Hong Kong. Sex reassignment surgeries (SRS) are on the rise in the country as it is similar in almost every country in the world. At this wake, it is disputable to fix the clash between legal and logical spheres of the case that relates to the right of a person to perceived sexuality. This case takes into consideration the implication of the verdict on the social spectrum of the transsexual with regards to his/her legal rights as a spouse especially in immigration apart from considering this as an issue of an individual’s intellectual right to choose a life of his desired sexuality. A large majority of the people are able to identify the gender of a person from the secondary sexual indicators on his anatomical frame such as the body hair, breasts, voice or the size of the body. Exploration of the body’s primary gender detective indications like the DNA structure where the chromosome pattern reads XX for female and XY for male is necessary only for the forensic information on issues related to investigations absolutely legal. The issue arises on the conflict between the biological sex of a person and his psychological sex, which drives him on the transsexual way. Procedural history of the issues taken at the courts of law in various prominent countries exemplifies the legal disadvantages of undergoing a treatment aimed at changing the biological sex in pursuit of obtaining the psychological sex. WHO considers the case of transsexual surgeries as Gender Identity Disorder (GID), (which is red with provisions of Gender Dysphoria in UK). However, the term is different from a conglomerate appearance disparity resulting in identification of the gender of a person by appearance inflicted by cross-dressing, transgender behavior or distinguished congenital conditions. Hormonal treatments targeting the sexuality alteration of individuals are scanned and monitored by the government of Hong Kong with several programs to deal with the GID issue. As the hospitals are surgically equipped with provisions for transsexual surgeries, they discharge the patient with a post operative gender change certificate for the social validity. But the legal provisions of the government takes a complex way to fix his gender change in the passport and national identity card of the person with an argument that the original gender has to be confirmed as on the time of birth. This argument is underlined by the provisional disallowance of any new technically altered gender for identification of the sexuality status of the person as per law. Anatomical sex is superior to psychological sex in terms of law. Therefore an alteration employed in the sexuality of a person with intent to satiate his desires of being the opposite sex becomes a matter out of any legal frame. Thus SRS can be considered as a personal risk undertaken by the individual against the normality of nature’s distribution to his gender which is prominently the basis for gender identification by the law. Hence any marriage or conjugal relationship becomes null and void at the hearing of a case on the petition to claim matrimonial rights after the decease of either spouse. Moreover, the terms ‘man’ and ‘woman’ are legally and anatomically defined by the constitutions of almost every country; therefore consummative challenges inflicted by SRS cannot form part of genetic disorders as malfunctioning of genitals and improper appearance of secondary sexual features of people. The law of Hong Kong, UK, Argentina and every other country suggests that marriage is a contractual bond between two natural individuals of perfect opposite sexuality inherited by birth which supports the operation of a normative life as guided by the society, which shall only be entitled to enjoy the rights of marital recognition under any provision of the law. When marriage is considered as the legal unity of two individuals to lead a sexually organized life, it is essential to have adherence to the provisions of law of the nation. There are several resemblances of the legal norms of the two countries, Hong Kong and the UK in terms of marriage acts. As marriage is a legal contract, it has to fulfill the clauses relating to the conditional applications of the law on every aspect with gender taking no exemption. Legality of the identification of gender of people different from the normal terms like ’sex’ ‘male’ and ‘female’ becomes tough as the provisional assignments of an amendment in the societal view of the issue is far remote in many civilized communities. Inclusion of a person suffering from transsexualism with disinterest towards cross dressing adds to the worry of the society. When such people undergoes SRS and get changed, it becomes difficult for him to find a place in the gender specified society. As reverse surgery is not easy in many of the cases because the natural organs once removed cannot be implanted. This causes the person to suffer greater grief during his post operative unsatisfactory acquired life in the society. For the benefit of the case mentioned in the argument, right to marry is guaranteed under article 37 of the Basic Law and article 19(2) of the Hong Kong Bill of Rights. Interpretations of the provisions of marriage law of Hong Kong with those of European Court of law suggest that a provisional consent can be granted on the issue of same sex marriage as per the article 37. The applicant is a female, who has undergone SRS and chose her desired male sex with intent to marry a female of her choice at one context and at another context, a male changes his anatomical features to acquire his psychological gender to get the approval of his marriage with a person of his desire. These two issues have to be treated with equal weight of legality. However, in the constitutional context of the applicants plead for a grant of her right to marriage; it is the court that should decide the legality of the marriage as to belong to same-sex marriage or transsexual marriage. Legitimacy of a person’s social identity as of a recognizable gender is sometimes challenged when the legal relaxation of the gender transformation is prevailed in some countries. There can be chances of people undergoing SRS after having committed serious criminal offenses. Identification of their gender becomes difficult for the investigative teams and they can escape the clutches of law with their amazingly new identity change. There can also be proportionate indicatives of people evading past marital records during their search for a new married life without the information and consent of the former partner by undergoing transsexual surgeries. However, the legal implication of the issue of somebody’s optional movement for selective gender transition becomes a problem to any court of law as it needs the amendment in the provisions related to identification of sexuality and determination of gender for the provisional agreement for a marital relationship. Civil Partnership Act 2004 of UK ensures the legal rights of partners bound by marriage on production of a certificate of identification of gender for the association of legal provisions for conjugal rights. In America, Brazil, Argentina, New Zealand and Australia, transsexual identity is legally approved and the partners involving in the marital contract are entitled to obtain a certificate of post operative gender which can be attached to their birth certificate for the amendments in the provisions of gender specification in their national identity card and passport. In some Asian countries like Japan, South Korea, Malaysia and Singapore, gender change is permissible and the post operative transsexual can choose a partnership life with the approval of marriage regulation laws. From the light of observations made on the narrative indices and detailed interpretation of legal implications of the GID issues mentioned in the case study it is understood that the legal provisions of the contractual relationship, termed as ‘marriage’ should have a uniform procedure to follow. Since the conjugal unity of ‘man’ and ‘woman’ is desirably meant for the happy life and reproduction of identical offspring, it should feature natural pattern of relationship as a generalization. However, intervention of new technologies to administer the challenges against nature’s choice comfortably alters the fundamental belief that marriages are the social umbrellas under which two individuals of opposite sex live together and bring forth their children. On the contrary, it has to be admitted that if the law provides for the change of a person’s gender from anatomical to psychological; it must also ensure him provisions for legality of his post operative marriages as per his desire because, marriage is a fundamental right when he is of a desirably able gender irrespective of the person’s reproductive ability. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Case Summary Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Case Summary Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1572331-case-summary
(Case Summary Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
Case Summary Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1572331-case-summary.
“Case Summary Term Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1572331-case-summary.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Issue of Transsexual Marriage in Hong Kongs State Law

Japanese Culture

It was a basic part of Japanese law as well that tried entire families for offences and not just the individual; however, the system is no longer in practice.... Yome means a Bride or daughter-in-law in Japanese or a more polite term would be ‘oyome-san'.... They were officially recognized by the Japanese government in 1899 and another law was passed in 2008 that not only granted them recognition, but decreed a complete eradication of discrimination against them....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Heteronormativity and the Exclusion of Bisexuality

Therefore, it is possible for sexism to arise if the issue of gender is imposed on people based only on their sex disregarding other factors that can shape the sexuality of a person.... Human sexuality is a topic that has been of controversy given that there are diverse opinions on the issue....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

When Is Immorality Not Enough to Cause Harm

Generally, the need for society to protect itself from potential destruction or disintegration is increasingly becoming the primary issue in the enactment of the new criminal law that is hinged on morality as espoused by the church despite today's prevailing policy in the separation of church and state.... The law it adopts is a tapestry of many shades of gray.... They argue that the teachings of religion are the basis of law and civil society and that a society that discourages the promulgation of those beliefs cannot function....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Legal Aspect of Transsexuals

At the turn of the century where egalitarian mentality provoked social change and global recognition geared towards the recognition of transsexual rights saw the greater acceptance in the concept of sexual orientation.... In the field of sexual orientation the protection of transsexual rights of gay and lesbian under Article 8 of the European Convention has been interpreted "to extend to an adult's right to participate in private, consensual homosexual activity"....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

Is America a False Hope for Transexuals

Go to Wikipedia, and you will be inundated with a huge variety of external links, each one catering to a very specific type of transsexual.... We see that while doing this, the issue becomes very tricky indeed.... n order to dispel some of these misconceptions, we need to first of all define what it means to be a transsexual, and then later confront each of the misconceptions surrounding the identities of these people.... Ask most individuals what it means to be a "transsexual," and the answer is fairly cut-and-dry: you will be met with the response, "A transsexual is someone who has chosen to reassign his or her gender through surgery, hormones, clothing, grooming and lifestyle....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Hong Kong Conflict of Laws

One example, is the case of Hayim v Citibank6 which was an appeal from Hong Kong involving issues of trust with Plaintiff's will having been made in hong Kong.... When the intentions of the parties to a contract are “neither expressed nor to be inferred from the circumstances,” then the system of law with which the transaction has its closest and most real connection will be held to be the proper law of the contract1.... t out in the case of Bonython v Commonwealth of Australia2where Lord Simonds in formally recognizing that the proper law to govern a contract can be arrived at objectively by looking at the contractual terms and circumstances surrounding the formation of contract, equated this This principle was also applied by Bingham J in the case of The Iran Vojdan, where a clause for dispute settlement provided for (a) Iranian law in Iran (b) German law in Hamburg and (c) English law in London....
5 Pages (1250 words) Term Paper

EMPLOYMENT LAW(EQUAL PAY LAWS-ARE THE ADEQUATE

Again, if differentials persist, it would be incumbent upon the part of the employers to state and prove the reasons for such differences were due to material reasons other than the choice of gender discrimination.... The main aims and desired objective of this study is to examine the effectiveness and potency of current Equal Pay laws both in the context of European Union (EU) legislatures and also with regard to employment laws in the United Kingdom impacting upon pay and benefits of the....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Truth in Human Sexuality in a World of Diversity

The authors of Human Sexuality in a World of Diversity give prominence to the issue of sexuality by highlighting in childhood and in adulthood.... The paper "Truth in Human Sexuality in a World of Diversity" states that the authors seem to indirectly advocate that heterosexual orientation is the norm in society....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us