StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The book review "Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas" states that Every one of us in this day and age is fascinated by Galileo’s conflict with the Church and the ecclesiastical authorities, and this book “Galileo in Rome” is a source to enable us to delve into the events…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas"

Book Report Galileo in Rome: The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius William R Shea and Mariano Artigas Every one of us in this day and age is fascinated by Galileo’s conflict with the Church and the ecclesiastical authorities, and this book “Galileo in Rome” is a great source to enable us to delve into the events that ultimately brought about the Inquisition. The book seems to be an original endeavor on the part of the authors to illustrate Galileo’s time and its complex environment. The six trips that Galileo made to Rome encompassed his lifetime; from the time he went looking for a job in a university in 1587 to the day when he faced the trial in 1633. It deals with a series of events climaxing into Galileo’s trial by the Tribunal of the Inquisition charging him of heresy. The charge against him was brought regarding his publication, Dialogue of the Two Chief World Systems in 1632. Through this publication Galileo expressed his views on certain fundamental scientific truth. The authors are, William R Shea, who held the chair of History of Science at the University of Padua at the time of writing this book, and Mariano Artigas, Professor of Philosophy of Science at the University of Navarra. They came by Galileo’s correspondence in the archive, which was the entire source on which this book is based. They actually speak of two Inquisitions, one in 1616 and the other in 1633. The trial is to be seen in the light of that age when science was just in an emerging state and people were not ready to part with the age-old traditional concepts and embrace challenges of scientific hypotheses. Galileo made his first trip to Rome as an unemployed youth in search of a university job. At this time he found favor with the leading Jesuit Mathematician Christopher Clavius, and perhaps met the future Cardinal Robert Bellarmine also who would play a significant role in Galileo’s future. His second trip to Rome was a glorious experience in his lifetime. He was already a famous professor. The celestial bodies observed through the telescope and their subsequent publication made him famous throughout the world of the intelligentsia. The Jesuit astronomers supported his discoveries, and Cardinal Bellarmine felicitated Galileo on his wonderful achievement. Galileo was granted a membership in the prestigious Accademia dei Lincei. Galileo’s third trip to Rome was clouded with antagonism against his active support for Copernicus and his heliocentric theory in his Letters to the Grand Duchess of Tuscany. The work on sunspots aggravated the suspicion. The authors narrate a series of events that sealed Galileo’s fate. The major event was that Galileo failed to prove the truth of Copernicus’s theory. According to Shea and Artigas, “ Had Galileo been able to demonstrate the truth of Copernicanism, all would have been well, but he did not have and was never to have such proof”. This is a vital reason that made the Church reject his theory. We have to take into account what persons even in the highest echelons of the Church had in their mind set. Cardinal Bellarmine in a letter to Antonio Foscarini mentioned “the sun goes down and hastens to his place where he arose etc, were those of Salomon, who not only spoke by divine inspiration but was a man above all others and most learned in the human sciences… His wisdom was from God”. He wrote this in answer to Foscarini’s recent published work in which he argued that the Scripture was a piece of literature to be understood by the common man and thus devoid of scientific language. Shea and Artigas take note that Bellarmine did not consider that biblical statements about the motion of the sun were just an unexamined assumption, but immediately expressed his own theological conviction that there can be no errors in the holy writ. Galileo took a bold stand that perhaps the Bible was not to be interpreted literally. In his Letter to Castelli, he joined for the first time a debate over the relation that existed between theology and science. The Letter reached the Holy Office and was duly examined. Before this, Prince Frederic Cesi had forewarned Galileo against further discussion on Copernicanism. However, his Letter was officially examined, several meetings of the Tribunal of the Inquisition made investigations on Copernicanism. It was officially declared that Copernicus’ theory on Heliocentrism was “false and against the Scriptures”. Copernicus’ book was stopped from further publication until corrections were made. Chapter IV narrates Galileo’s fourth journey to Rome. Berberini was elected to be the next Pope and he took UrbanVIII as his new name. Galileo had high hopes that he would find favor with the new Pope, as Berberini, a fellow Florentine, had appreciated him previously. But then the tide started running against him. His fifth trip to Rome was made in order to publish his book Dialogue. His intention remained unsuccessful because of sudden death of prince Federico Cesi. During this time Galileo tried to convince Pope UrbanVIII to allow him to write his book. His permission came along with a few stipulations. Galileo went back convinced that he could write the book on condition that Galileo’s claim would be that it was written on hypotheses. Let us take into account what Galileo’s Dialogue is. In this book Galileo told the story of two-world system through the voices of his two close friends, Filippo Salviati and Giovanfrancesco Sagredo. Another fictional character was Simplicio, who had neither wit nor intelligence. But Simplicio was also the name of a Greek philosopher, famous for his commentary on Aristotle. In his book he commented on Aristotelian misconception that the earth related Physics could not be applied to heaven. He cited examples of the mountains on the moon. He dealt with Earth’s movement, and the solar system. Then he argued that the Earth turned like all other planets and circled the sun. In the voice of Simplicio, however, he expressed the argument that the Pope had presented to him. Galileo’s adversaries (he had quite a few) brought this to the Pope’s attention. The Pope became angry as he thought that he had been ridiculed. Galileo did not concern himself about any possible consequences of his book as he had prior permission to write this. Father Riccardi had reassured Castelli that Galileo would have no problem publishing his book. . Riccardi at the time did not feel any real threat about Copenicanism. It is to be noted that neither Castelli nor Riccardi knew the true implications of the book. Father Riccardi was neither concerned with Ptolemy nor with Copernicus. But he was perfectly content with the heavenly bodies being moved by angels. Had he warned Galileo in time, he would not have to face charges that he did. Even as the Pope gave Galileo’s Dialogue for examination, the political turmoil within the Church forced the Pontiff to ban a few Spanish rebel priests. Castelli, Galileo’s staunch advocate was exiled. The frail and weak with age Astronomer was summoned to Rome to face charges about what he was not informed at all. Galileo’s fate was sealed by a lot of events that can be read beyond the controversies between religion and science. Pope UrbanVIII, it is said had been pressurized from many quarters. Critics had charged him that he was lenient with the heretics. The Lutherans had been forcing the Catholic Church to impart a more literal interpretation of the Scripture. In April 1633, Galileo was brought to face charges brought against him. Galileo, whom Einstein called the Father of Modern Science, was forced to kneel down and made to say the following words, “My error has been one of vainglorious ambition, pure ignorance and inadvertence”. Works cited: 1.Shea, R William, Artigas, Mariano “The Galileo Affair”, January2006, Facultades de Cincias y Eclesiastica de Filosofia, Universidad de Navarra, Pamplona, Spain 18April.2008 < http://www.unav.es/cryf/galileoaffair.html > Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas Book Report/Review, n.d.)
Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1545817-galileo-in-rome-book-report
(Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas Book Report/Review)
Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/history/1545817-galileo-in-rome-book-report.
“Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1545817-galileo-in-rome-book-report.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Church in The Rise and Fall of an Uneasy Genius by Artigas

Film Critique on The Movie Gladiator

The Final Film Critique: Gladiator Name University Introduction On the onset of a new millennium, the euphoria of embracing a new century was at its peak.... The survivors at the auspicious moment did witness a remarkable moment, and the year was followed by events that were celebrated keeping in mind the fateful event of embracing the millennium....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Jewish Trial of Jesus in Marks Gospel

Understanding and evaluation of any piece of literature depends a lot on experience and background.... This may explain why perspectives for everyone in this regard differ somewhat.... The same with appraising any piece of writing.... The background of recorded events must be considered in order to appreciate nuances of those events....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Contrasting Views of Childhood

Industrialization had set in and French revolution was lulled into an uneasy calm only a few months ago, with the adventurer Napoleon now at the helm of French affairs.... Childhood, the beginning of life and its experiences, define and direct the entire life and considered by sociologists and psychologists as the very core of life itself....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Spanish Golden Age Painting

In all the cases the creative genius behind the works remained, despite the calculations of their patrons and rulers, enigmatic and unpredictable.... At the same time, the unpredictability with which artistic genius reacts to its surrounding circumstances will be respected at all times....
20 Pages (5000 words) Essay

Opera house public environment

igital sales, while on the rise, are not making up difference.... Although its association with the university is primarily what makes Princeton a college town, other important institutions in the area include the Institute for Advanced Study, Westminster Choir College, Princeton Plasma Physics Laboratory, Princeton Theological Seminary, Opinion Research Corporation, Siemens Corporate Research, SRI International, FMC Corporation, The Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, Amrep, church and Dwight, Berlitz International, and Dow Jones & Company....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

History of Commincation

This essay describes major trends during the years.... Renaissance era is the era of the 14th and the 17th century that was in Europe.... The era is the time between the middle ages and the modern history and it focuses on significant technology advancement in the region.... hellip; Amid the late Middle Ages, European countries experienced incredibly war and also from an infection that influenced their well-being and economy....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Scenography and the Role of Architectural Representation in the Production of Contemporary Architecture

The paper, Critical Tools to Investigate the Role of Architectural Representation, concentrates on scenography as one of these critical tools.... Scenography is an important tool in investigating the role of architectural representation in the production of contemporary architecture.... hellip; This paper examines architectural representation across a wide historical period, with an emphasis on the relationship between scenography and architecture in different historical periods: from the Renaissance to the contemporary world....
22 Pages (5500 words) Research Paper

Visual Images and Managing Behavior, Values and Social Relationships

This coursework "Visual Images and Managing Behavior, Values and Social Relationships" discusses the role of visual imagery in managing behavior, values and social relationships.... nbsp;Visual images have always been used to convey messages in the representation of the modern world.... hellip; Visual culture has undergone an evolution since the times of renaissance up to now....
12 Pages (3000 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us