StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Over-education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
The coursework " Over-education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK" describes the problem of over educations and its reasons. This paper outlines job dissatisfaction, lower-wage payment, the lack of human capital, sufficient lack of vocational, and managerial skills training…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Over-education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Over-education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK"

Over-education in the graduate labour market of UK Executive Summary The labour market in U.K is full of graduates who are involved in jobs that do not require a graduation degree. This results in over education of the candidate. This leads to job dissatisfaction and also lower wage payment. The fact that the number of the graduates is increasing every year plays a major role. The job requirements are lesser than the number of vacancies in market. Moreover, the lack of human capital also leads to over education. The graduation degree often, do not provide sufficient job related skills to the students, so, the student although end up having a graduation degree, but they do not possess sufficient vocational skills. The education system is not yet fully designed to curb this issue. There is sufficient lack of vocational and managerial skills training, which needs to be removed by changing the subject curriculum. The employers are reluctant to fully utilize the skills of the graduate employees. There is also a significant wage discrepancy among the new graduates, which enhances their perception of being over qualified. Thus, the problem of over education can only be solved if the entire education system as well as the labour market is re-oriented in order to facilitate right jobs for the right skill set. Table of Contents Introduction 4 Over education in UK labour market 4 Conclusion 7 Reference list 8 Introduction This paper is an attempt to find out the trend of the labour market in U.K, its relationship with the academic structure and whether the graduates are over qualified for the job they are doing. This study will help to understand the condition of the labour market and whether the education in the graduate level is yielding the right jobs for the students. Over the last decade the supply of graduate students has increased rapidly and also the cost to graduate has been reduced too, these factors have eventually led to lack of employment. Thus graduates end up getting jobs below their skill level (Dolton & Siles. 2003). The overcrowding of universities with prospective graduates has led to decline of their market value. This increases competition among them, as the number of people having the same level of skill, is more than the number of vacancies in the labour market. The lack of right skill versus job compatibility usually brings job dissatisfaction among the employees and also it decreases the value of graduate level education (Battu & Sloane. 2004). Over education in UK labour market Over education can arise from the deficit of human capital. Peter. J Dolton stated that, a worker may need additional education to compensate for the decencies of other aspects of human capital. To put it simply, a job requirement depends on the individual’s accumulated resource of human capital which include previous work experience, on job training, etc, and not just formal education. According to occupational mobility theory, it is suggested that, if the deficiency of skills can be rectified with training and work experience then the over qualification can be eliminated eventually. However, if the difference between the job skill requirement and the skill level of an average graduate is more, then the elimination of over education is a long term process (Dolton & Silles. 2001). The variation of college or institution quality can also explain the rise of over qualified workers. If a student graduates from a lower quality college ends up having the same job a higher level college graduate has, then the individual from the lower level college is not over qualified. The additional education provided in the higher level college may be necessary for the job requirement. But in contrast to the lower level college graduate, the higher level college graduate is definitely over qualified (National Statistics. 2013). Arnaud Chevalier and Joanne Lindley stated that, their studies only found limited evidence of lack of academic skills in over qualified graduates. So, the increase in number of graduates cannot be related to the reduction of acquired skills by the graduates (Rubb. 2003). The real difference comes in the lack of managerial and leadership skills in the genuinely over qualified workers. Moreover, the over qualified graduates had university academic skills, but they were left will unfavourable labour market and unobserved skills (Chevalier. 2003). They also stated that the quality of university education may not be the deciding factor. The graduates who pass out from new universities, were supposed to have low quality education, but they had the same probability of being over qualified, like the graduate from a reputed university. Managerial, entrepreneurial and labour market skills largely reduce the risk of over qualification. The determinants of over education before and after the rise in number of graduates, was fairly similar (Chevalier & Lindley. 2007). Francis Green’s study however shows that, over qualification can be grouped into “Formal Over qualification” and “Real over qualification”. In case of formal over qualification, the employees mentioned that, they ended up having below graduate level jobs, but they did not mention that they are under utilizing their acquired skills. This group comprised of 23% of the graduates by 2006 (Green & Zhu. 2010). Whereas, in case of Real over qualification, the employees report that they are over qualified and they also under utilize their skills. The number of “Really” over qualified workers is rising gradually. The “real” over qualification comes with significantly more job dissatisfaction than the “formal” over qualification. Considering this trend, it is stated that, whether because of increasing cost of each employees or increasing in the prevalence, the problem of over qualification would increase over time (Bauer. 2002) On the contrary, Ian Walker and Yu Zhu stated that, despite of the rapid increase of graduates in the labour market, it was seen that, there was a significant fall in the job returns of recently graduated cohorts in all subjects. This was true for both men and women. They also found that, for men as well as for women, there was an increase in number of engineering and math degree holders getting jobs of graduate level, and this return shows a rising trend. The wage penalty faced by an over educated employee can be explained by the difference between the unobserved and observed skill levels (Walker & Zhu. 2005). Se´amus McGuinness pointed out in his studies that, the determining factors of wage rates in economy are both the individual and job characteristics. The impacts of over education were likely to be a non-trivial one and the phenomenon may be costly to both the graduates and the organizations and more importantly the economy (McGuinness & Wooden. 2009). The government’s decision of pursuing 50 percent higher education target has been questioned (OECD .2005). Their studies have shown that, post expansion of graduates, the over education cases have increased in both men and women, across all the subjects. Subjects like Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences have seen a much rapid growth of over educated graduates. So, clearly if the graduation participation continues in line with government’s pursuit, then the number of over educated workers will increase, which in turn will incur additional costs on the individuals, on the organization and the economy as a whole (Meager. 2008). This phenomenon asks for re-orientation in the education system of UK by the government, and more focus should be put on vocational training and managerial courses which has greater level of skills required for jobs. Though, this strategy should help curb the over education problem, but this alone is not a sufficient solution. The problem effectively lies in the oversupply of educated individuals, than what the labour market requires. The organizations are also unwilling to change their operation processes to fully utilize the skills of the employees (McGuinness. 2006). Mary Silles along with Peter Dolton conducted a study in which they concluded that, pay differential associated with an educational discrepancy is found in the early labour market entrant. The primary determinant of over education is the low work ability of the graduates. This work ability creates a productivity differential between graduate employees and earnings. They also stated wage of an employee is dependent on the subject of graduation. The graduates of Arts and Humanities earn less than the engineering graduates and graduates working in the educational field also earn less than other faculties (Silles &Dolton. 2002). Conclusion The over education in the UK is a problem which will continue to grow, if the labour market does not re-orient its recruitment structure. The employers should find out ways of fully utilizing the skills of the new entrants, as a result, the employee will no longer be over qualified for the job and at the same time, the organizations productivity will also increase. The government also has a role to play in pursuit of reducing the over qualification of the graduates. It can make certain changes in the education system and subject curriculum. The curriculum should be so designed that it prepares the student for the labour market. The education should be in line with the skill requirements in job industry. Moreover, if the human capital deficiency can be reduced by encouraging students in to more managerial skill training, then the problem of over qualification can be kept under control. Reference list Battu, H., and Sloane, P., 2004. Over-education and ethnic minorities in Britain. The Manchester School, 72 (4), pp.535-559. Bauer, T., 2002. Educational mismatch and wages: a panel analysis. Economics of Education Review 21, pp.221–229 Chevalier, A., and Lindley, J., 2007. Over- Education and the Skills of UK graduate. Centre for the Economics of Education. August, pp.5-10. Chevalier, A., 2003. Measuring over-education. Economica, 70 (279), pp.509-531 Dolton, P., and Silles, M., 2001. Over-Education in the Graduate Labour Market: Some Evidence from Alumni Data. Centre for the Economics of Education. June, pp.17-27 Dolton, P., and Siles, M., 2003. The determinants and consequences of overeducation. In Buchel, de Grip and Mertens (eds), Overeducation in Europe, pp.189–217. Green, F., and Zhu, Y., 2010. Overqualification, job dissatisfaction, and increasing dispersion in the returns to graduate education. Oxford Economic Papers. 24 (1), pp.4-21. McGuinness, S., 2006. Overeducation In The Labour Market. Melbourne Journal of Economic Surveys, 20 (3), pp.401-414. McGuinness, S., and Wooden, M., 2009. Overskilling, job insecurity and career mobility. Industrial Relations, 48, pp.265–86. Meager, N., 2008. The Role of Training and Skills Development in Active Labour Market Policies. Institute for Employment Studies, April, pp.10-17. National Statistics. 2013. Full Report - Graduates in the UK Labour Market 2013. Office for national Statistics, November, pp.3-27. OECD.2005. Labour Market Programmes and Activation Strategies: Evaluating the Impacts, in: OECD Employment Outlook 2005, ch.4, pp.178-183. Rubb, S., 2003. Overeducation: A short or long run phenomenon for individuals? Economics of Education Review, 22, pp.389–94. Silles, M and Dolton, P. 2002. The Effects Of Over-Education On Earnings In The Graduate Labour Market. Department Of Economics. Discussion Paper Series, 126, pp.1-18. Walker, I., and Zhu, Y., 2005. The College Wage Premium, Overeducation, and the Expansion of Higher Education in the UK. Institute for the Study of Labor, 1627, pp.4-22. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Over-education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1, n.d.)
Over-education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 1. https://studentshare.org/education/1843367-over-education-in-the-graduate-labour-market-researched-literature-review
(Over-Education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1)
Over-Education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/education/1843367-over-education-in-the-graduate-labour-market-researched-literature-review.
“Over-Education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 1”. https://studentshare.org/education/1843367-over-education-in-the-graduate-labour-market-researched-literature-review.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Over-education in the Graduate Labour Market of UK

Specific Economic Problem Currently Affecting UK

An author of the essay "Specific Economic Problem Currently Affecting uk" points out that teenagers tend to finance not only their personal expenditures and family but also their educational expenses.... It should be highlighted that the uk's economy was adversely impacted due to the worst recession of 2008 - 2009, which led to a significant decline in aggregate consumption.... It should be highlighted that uk's economy was adversely impacted due to worst recession of 2008 - 2009, which led to the significant decline in aggregate consumption....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Is Current Government Policy On Training And Development Fit for Purpose

With the problems arising in the educational sector in the region, such as falling stay on rates, inadequacy and shortfall of skills in the labour market and quality of education, these policies were found to be extremely effective and improved the quality and level of education substantially in the sector.... … According to the report since the post war period, the uk government has made a number of modifications in its education system.... There were major reforms undertaken for addressing the problems of the education system in uk....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Entrepreneurship and Small Business: Case of Clippy London

Calypso and her mother Clare chose to manufacture the bags from uk and use their house as the office.... Instead of that if that if both the unit in uk the orders can be more quickly handled.... helped her to find out a manufacturer from uk (Smith, 2010).... These three were the main reason of choosing uk as the place of manufacturing for calypso for her fashionable see through bag with customised designs.... During start ups and initial growth period manufacturing unit of Clippy was at uk, there were some advantages as well as some disadvantages also....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Integrated Quality Assurance Principles in the Teaching-Learning Environment

This can be done by monitoring how the alumni from the college are performing in the market.... If after checking it becomes clear that the alumni of the college are not doing so well in the market, the college may have to look at the syllabus and the implementation of the syllabus and look for any issues which may be causing variance between the planned and the achieved results (International Labour Office, 2010)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Development Trends Of The UKs Economy

The paper "Development Trends Of The uk's Economy" discusses how the uk's economy evolving to accommodate the changes that are taking place at the global level.... hellip; The current state of the uk's manufacturing sector will indicate that it is in recession and as discussed above, it may start to lose its ranking as one of the leading manufacturing economies of the world.... The uk is the 6th largest manufacturing economy of the world, however; its total contribution is gradually declining since 1977....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us