StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Human Genome Project / genetic discrimination based on testing for harmful genes - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Genetic discrimination is a form of discrimination especially by employers or insurance companies based on possession of perceived harmful genes that exposes a person to the risk of developing a chronic condition. Records of genetic tests are included in medical records…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.6% of users find it useful
Human Genome Project / genetic discrimination based on testing for harmful genes
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Human Genome Project / genetic discrimination based on testing for harmful genes"

Human Genome Project genetic discrimination based on testing for “harmful” genes Genetic discrimination is a form ofdiscrimination especially by employers or insurance companies based on possession of perceived harmful genes that exposes a person to the risk of developing a chronic condition. Records of genetic tests are included in medical records. Insurers and employers have a right to accessing this information. Genetic test records may form the basis of decisions made by parities such as insurers and employers and this negatively affects the people with the “wrong gene” (Schoonmaker and Williams 30).

The groups working on the Human Genome Project has recognized possibility of genetic discrimination and has suggested that results of genetic tests should not be used to make decisions on eligibility for insurance cover or employment. They have also suggested that third parties should not have access to that information except through written permission of the person who owns the test records. Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) of 1996 protect people against genetic discrimination.

However, where employer and insurers have access to the records, there is no guarantee that people will not be discriminated against. For example, although discrimination based on gender and race is illegal, evidence shows that people or color face barriers to accessing employment and women face obstacles that prevent them from leadership positions. The same applies to people with disability. This means that making genetic discrimination illegal does not guarantee that employers and insurers will always comply (Schoonmaker and Williams 23).

Genetic testing is likely to contribute to increased cases of discrimination for those in possession of the wrong gene. Genetic testing is useful in some cases. For example, some people who carry the gene HLA-DPB1 have beryllium sensitivity and chronic beryllium disease. Genetic test can reveal this occupation hazard for the people with this gene in the workplace. However, in circumstances where the company wants to lay off workers, people with the gene may be the first to be laid off as their condition may be considered by the company as a liability.

This suggests that genetic discrimination even where advantages of genetic test are obvious could still be used to victimize people (Maheu 12). Another danger of genetic tests stems from American experience with eugenics. Eugenic movement was strong in America in the 19th century. It was even widely accepted in the academic community. The early proponents of eugenics were prominent scientists and influential people in society. This movement advocated for measures such as prevention of disabled people and imbeciles from having children.

Margaret Singer supported birth control as a measure of preventing unwanted children from being born in disadvantaged life (Gehring 20). Mentally retarded people were even isolated to prevent them from breeding with the rest of the people. Laws were passed for the sterilization of people who were mentally retarded. California sterilized as many as 60,000 within 50 years starting from 1909 (Gehring 24). Eugenic movement also sought to bar immigration restrictions into America from people considered racially inferior to the genetically superior Anglo-Saxon stock.

American eugenic movement influenced Nazi Germany racial policies that considered non Germans and especially Slavic, Jews, blacks and other people as racially inferior (Gehring 23). As late as 1994 Richard Herrnstein and Charles Murray sought to provide empirical evidence that suggest that intelligence varies with race. American history of discrimination against racial minorities and disabled people including the mentally retarded suggest that genetic test may provide scientific evidence to justify discrimination.

People with genes that increase the risk of developing serious condition may face discrimination. Works CitedGehring, Verna V.. Genetic prospects: essays on biotechnology, ethics, and public policy. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, 2003. Print.Maheu, Louis. Challenging genetic determinism new perspectives on the gene in its multiple environments. Montreal: McGill-Queens University Press, 2011. Print.Schoonmaker, Michele, and Erin Dominique Williams. Genetic testing scientific background and nondiscrimination legislation.

New York: Novinka Books, 2006. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Human Genome Project / genetic discrimination based on testing for Essay”, n.d.)
Human Genome Project / genetic discrimination based on testing for Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/biology/1634304-human-genome-project-genetic-discrimination-based-on-testing-for-harmful-genes
(Human Genome Project / Genetic Discrimination Based on Testing for Essay)
Human Genome Project / Genetic Discrimination Based on Testing for Essay. https://studentshare.org/biology/1634304-human-genome-project-genetic-discrimination-based-on-testing-for-harmful-genes.
“Human Genome Project / Genetic Discrimination Based on Testing for Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/biology/1634304-human-genome-project-genetic-discrimination-based-on-testing-for-harmful-genes.
  • Cited: 1 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Human Genome Project / genetic discrimination based on testing for harmful genes

Individuals Differing in Gender

A few speculations and possibilities are proposed based on the statistical results.... Two datasets of individuals differing in gender are analyzed statistically with respect to various psychological variables.... However it should be clarifies that these results are solely subject to the demographics of the dataset, their socio economical positioning and limited by sample size. ...
12 Pages (3000 words) Statistics Project

Wage Discrimination in the US Labor Market

discrimination on various fronts has been a hot debate in the US since the end of slave trade and in the years following the subsequent passage of the law abolishing slave trade.... The paper will also investigate possible reasons for the disparity in earnings- whether it is due to skills or discrimination.... We then review the principle models of racial discrimination in the labor market and discuss their ability to explain the observed differences....
6 Pages (1500 words) Statistics Project

Toxicant Scavenger Hunt

ong term effects of human exposure… Along with pulmonary and hypertensive potentials.... Exposure to cigarette smoke s quite common, however, in large concentration in can be quite dangerous for one's health, Like uranium radioactive substances cause developmental flaws and in growth....
1 Pages (250 words) Statistics Project

Post-Earnings Announcement Drift

The data used in this paper considers four SUE portfolios based on events' quoted prices as one method of testing the PEAD phenomenon and examination of whether market over and under reaction usually exist through the use of event study methodology.... n this paper, the selection of the used sample was based on the consideration of all companies listed in the ASE.... ith respect to the perspectives of the efficient market hypothesis and the PEAD, this paper aims at testing the PEAD phenomenon on a non-American market, Greek market....
6 Pages (1500 words) Statistics Project

The Relationship between Gender and Personality

hellip; People's perceptions about other people to a large extend seem to be based on personal characteristics, for which most of the characteristics are due to personal life experiences.... Personality style is what could be described as preferences and perceptions based on such aspects.... This project explores the relationship between gender and certain styles of personality.... nbsp;The issue of personality remains to be pivotal in all aspects of human life....
11 Pages (2750 words) Statistics Project

Stop and Search Data in the Lynfield Local Police Force

This paper tells that the Lynfield local police force has collected the stop and search data for the last year.... The force wants analysis to be done on the data.... The police force wants to identify suitable trends that might define stop and search data for the last year.... hellip; The police force wants to ascertain if there are any trends that indicate disproportionate and/or discriminatory exercise of stop and search....
8 Pages (2000 words) Statistics Project

Homeownership vs Renting Comparisons of Males, Females, Couples, and Singles

"Homeownership vs.... Renting Comparisons of Males, Females, Couples and Singles and Other Trends in Real Estate" paper argues that while most single persons rent the places they live, apparently, they seek homeownership and this is evidence by the high percentage of single women and men who own homes… As a matter of fact, much associate homeownership with success....
6 Pages (1500 words) Statistics Project

Public Attitudes to the Impending 56th USA Presidential Election

The "Questions based on Published Findings from a Poll NYC Times Conducted to Investigate Attitudes to the Impending 56th US Presidential" paper examines the critical assessment of the data collection procedure and of the published newspaper article.... hellip; based on the article published by the New York Times, it can be found that 52 percent of the probable voters would vote for Obama and 39 percent will be voting for Mr....
6 Pages (1500 words) Statistics Project
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us